Can Gameplay Be Copyrighted?
In the dynamic landscape of creative works, the question of what can and can't be copyrighted often leaves ambiguities, particularly in the realm of gameplay, a unique form of expression that blends storytelling, art, and technology. So, can gameplay be copyrighted? The answer is nuanced and depends on several factors.
The Copyright Act of 1976 in the United States protects "original works of authorship fixed in any tangible medium of expression," including literary works. Gameplay, being a complex and intricate narrative structure, can indeed fall under this umbrella. However, the copyrightability of gameplay isn't as straightforward as it seems.
Protecting Gameplay Mechanics
Gameplay mechanics, the rules and systems that govern how a game works, can be protected by patents rather than copyrights. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has granted patents for game methods and systems, such as the patent for the Tetris game mechanic. This area of law is still evolving, with several high-profile patent disputes among gaming giants.
However, not all game mechanics are eligible for patent protection. To be patentable, an invention must be novel, non-obvious, and useful. Some game mechanics may be too abstract or obvious to meet these criteria.
Copyrighting Gameplay-as-Literature
In some respects, gameplay can be considered a form of literature, with copyright protection extending to its narrative, dialogue, and characters. For instance, the copyrightability of branching storylines in games like "Life is Strange" or "Until Dawn" is clear. These games' narratives unfold based on player choices, creating a unique form of interactive storytelling that can be copyrighted.
In the 2019 case "Video Game Makers Guild vs. Epic Games," the U.S. appeals court ruled that video games can be considered utterances under the Copyright Act, further solidifying their literary credentials and paving the way for copyright protection for their narratives.
Protecting Gameplay as Choreography
Gameplay can also be seen as a form of choreography, with copyright potentially extending to its movement patterns and sequences. Dance choreography enjoys copyright protection, and games like "Shadow of the Colossus" or "God of War" feature intricate, cinematic fight sequences that could fall under this category.
The strength of these choreography copyrights is still uncertain, given the difficulty of proving infringement without a clear record of the original work. However, they represent another avenue for game creators to seek protection for their unique ideas.
Copyrighting Gameplay as a Whole
The 1994 Supreme Court case "Feist Publications v. Rural Telephone Service," established that facts, ideas, and functional elements cannot be copyrighted. Applying this to games, the basic idea of a game (e.g., a platformer or a first-person shooter) isn't copyrightable. Nor are its functional elements, like respawn points or level progression.
Moreover, game code itself is primarily protected by software licensing and end-user license agreements (EULAs) rather than copyrights, as it's considered a functional element of a game. The games industry's heavy reliance on software updates, DLC, and online services makes copyright a less suitable form of protection for game code than traditional software licenses.
Copyrighting the Gameplay Experience
While the basic elements of gameplay might not be copyrightable, the unique experience a player has while playing a game could be. The way a game feels - its pacing, tone, and atmosphere - can be protected as an expression of its creators' vision, much like the "total concept and feel" of a movie can be protected by copyright.
In the case "Bridgeport Music, Inc. v.énom," the court ruled that copyright protection extends to the overall feel of a work. However, determining what constitutes a protectable "feel" in a game is still largely uncharted territory in copyright law.
In conclusion, while not all aspects of gameplay can be copyrighted, many aspects, such as its narrative, unique mechanics, and overall player experience, can indeed be protected. As games continue to push boundaries and blur the line between art and technology, so too must our understanding of their copyrightability. Lawyers, courts, and games industry professionals are all working together to shape this evolving field, giving rise to innovative solutions for protecting one of the 21st century's most dynamic forms of expression."