christmas decorations before thanksgiving

Debate: Decorate for Christmas Before Thanksgiving?

By Olivia Miller
AD

In the ongoing debate of when it's acceptable to start decking the halls, a controversial topic has emerged: Christmas decorations before Thanksgiving. Traditionally, Americans have followed the convention of waiting until after the fourth Thursday of November to bring out the tinsel and Christmas lights. But in recent years, this timeless tradition has come under fire, with some enthusiasts arguing that the earlier, the merrier when it comes to Christmas cheer.

With each passing year, more people seem to be embracing the idea of putting up their Christmas decorations earlier and earlier. A survey conducted by RetailMeNot found that more than half of Americans (54%) would start their holiday decorating before Thanksgiving. This shift begs the question: is it really so wrong to enjoy a bit of Christmas spirit before giving thanks?

Historical context and traditional norms

The rule of waiting until after Thanksgiving to start decorating for Christmas has its roots in American history. In the late 19th century, Christmas decorations were typically put up after the Thanksgiving feast, signaling the official start of the holiday season. This tradition stuck, and for over a century, it was widely observed.

AD
christmas decorations with the words how to decorate for christmas before thanksgiving
christmas decorations with the words how to decorate for christmas before thanksgiving
a table with candles and pine cones hanging from it
a table with candles and pine cones hanging from it
a wreath with orange slices and cinnamons hanging on a wooden wall next to a lit candle
a wreath with orange slices and cinnamons hanging on a wooden wall next to a lit candle

Even as late as the 1980s, retail stores would hold off on holiday promotions until the day after Thanksgiving, with families often waiting to put up their outdoor light displays until the weekend following the holiday. But as time has passed, the rules have gradually changed.

Changing consumer behavior

One of the primary reasons for the shift in decorating timelines can be attributed to the retail industry, which has increasingly focused on driving holiday sales earlier in the season. Black Friday, the day after Thanksgiving, has expanded into Black November, with many stores kicking off their holiday sales as early as the first week of the month.

an orange slice with cinnamons and pine cones around it on a piece of wood
an orange slice with cinnamons and pine cones around it on a piece of wood
cinnamon and orange slices hanging from strings
cinnamon and orange slices hanging from strings
a potted christmas tree sitting on top of a wooden crate next to a couch
a potted christmas tree sitting on top of a wooden crate next to a couch

As a result, consumers have grown accustomed to transacting earlier, which has indirectly influenced their behavior when it comes to displaying their Christmas spirit. It's simply become more convenient to shop and decorate in the weeks leading up to Thanksgiving.

Social media influence

Another significant factor driving the trend of Christmas decorations before Thanksgiving is the rise of social media. Platforms like Instagram and Pinterest have provided a constant stream of inspiration and ideas for holiday decor, encouraging users to share their festive creations with the world.

AD

With more people showing off their beautifully adorned homes and yards earlier in the season, others feel the pressure to keep up and join in the festivities. It's no longer just about having a perfectly decorated house; it's also about getting the most likes and shares on your social media channels.

three mason jars filled with orange slices and christmas lights
three mason jars filled with orange slices and christmas lights
someone is decorating an orange slice wreath with candles and greenery in the background
someone is decorating an orange slice wreath with candles and greenery in the background
a table set with white plates, silverware and an orange slice
a table set with white plates, silverware and an orange slice
some oranges are sitting on a table with other food items
some oranges are sitting on a table with other food items
Easy Diy For Christmas, Dehydrated Orange Decorations, Hanging Christmas Decoration, Dried Orange Decoration, Christmas Orange Decor, Crafts With Oranges, Useful Craft Ideas For Adults, Christmas Crafts For Adults Decoration, Tree Decorations Diy
Easy Diy For Christmas, Dehydrated Orange Decorations, Hanging Christmas Decoration, Dried Orange Decoration, Christmas Orange Decor, Crafts With Oranges, Useful Craft Ideas For Adults, Christmas Crafts For Adults Decoration, Tree Decorations Diy
10 Winter Pinecone Crafts Ideas with Cozy Cheer
10 Winter Pinecone Crafts Ideas with Cozy Cheer

Arguments for Christmas decorations before Thanksgiving

While some people may still scorn the idea of putting up their Christmas tree before Turkey Day, there are legitimate reasons why others embrace the trend earlier rather than later.

The Elf on the Shelf phenomenon has contributed to many families starting their holiday celebrations earlier. The popular books and toys encourage parents to create a daily Elf scene leading up to Christmas, kicking off the Christmas season early.

AD

Embrace the joy and magic

For many, the holiday season is about spreading joy and magic, and who's to say when that should start? If celebrating Christmas early brings happiness and excitement to a person's home, why should they be made to feel guilty or judged?

a christmas mantle decorated with gold coins and pine cones, lit by candles in the corner
a christmas mantle decorated with gold coins and pine cones, lit by candles in the corner

An early Christmas decoration might also serve as a welcome distraction from the stress and anxiety that comes with the colder months,ókay dark days, and the ongoing pandemic. In a world filled with uncertainty, a little extra Christmas cheer might be just what the doctor ordered.

Holiday exhaustion and burnout

On the other hand, some argue that starting the holiday season too late can lead to a rush and result in stress, exhaustion, and burnout. By beginning the celebrations earlier, people have more time to enjoy the season and avoid the last-minute scrambling often associated with Christmas preparations.

AD

An early start also allows for a longer holiday season, which might help in maintaining a festive mood and spreading the joy throughout the colder months.

Concerns and counterarguments

Despite the growing acceptance of Christmas decorations before Thanksgiving, there are still valid concerns and arguments against the trend.

Tradition and timing

For some, the issue is fundamentally about preserving tradition. Thanksgiving represents a time to give thanks for what we have and to reflect on our blessings before diving into the commercialism of Christmas. Starting the celebrations too early may diminish the significance of Thanksgiving and detract from the season of gratitude.

Moreover, putting up decorations earlier might also make the holiday season feel as though it drags on too long, potentially leading to decorations feeling worn out or outdated by the time Christmas finally arrives.

Neighborhood regulations and gatekeepers

Another concern is that of neighborhood regulations or homeowner associations (HOAs) that may have rules regarding the timing and duration of holiday decorations. While some may be lenient, others could impose fines or penalties for breaking the rules, creating unnecessary stress for homeowners simply trying to enjoy the season.

Additionally, the pressure to "keep up with the Joneses" by having a perfectly decorated home might place an unwanted financial strain on those who can't afford it, further exacerbating the spirit of the season.

In the end, the decision to put up Christmas decorations before Thanksgiving ultimately rests with the individual or family. There's no right or wrong answer, as both sides have valid points. Whether you choose to embrace the early festivities or hold out until after the Thanksgiving feast, what's truly important is that you enjoy the holiday season in a way that brings you happiness and joy.

AD