consumer reports grill buying guide

Consumer Reports Grill Buying Guide: Top Picks & Safer Grilling

By Steven Johnson
AD

When it comes to outdoor cooking, few appliances are as iconic and versatile as the grill. Whether you're a seasoned pitmaster or a novice just starting out, choosing the right grill is crucial for delighting your taste buds and impressing your guests. Consumer Reports has decoded the grill market to bring you this comprehensive buying guide, ensuring you make an informed decision.

Grills today come in various types, fuel sources, and sizes, each with its own set of advantages and considerations. Let's dive into the world of grills and help you find your perfect match.

Understanding Grill Types

Gas, charcoal, pellet - each grill type brings a unique cooking experience to the table. Let's explore the pros and cons of each.

AD
an image of a bbq grill with two burners and one side door open
an image of a bbq grill with two burners and one side door open
Is Your Grill Hot Enough?
Is Your Grill Hot Enough?
How to Grill Like a Pro - Consumer Reports
How to Grill Like a Pro - Consumer Reports

Gas Grills

Gas grills are beloved for their convenience and ease of use. They heat up quickly, offer precise temperature control, and clean-up is usually a breeze. Propane and natural gas are the two fuel options, with natural gas grills offering a constant supply of fuel via a pipeline, while propane tanks need to be replaced.

However, gas grills may not impart the same smoky flavor that charcoal grills can provide. They also tend to require more frequent maintenance to ensure optimal performance.

How to Choose a Grill - Consumer Reports
How to Choose a Grill - Consumer Reports
an advertisement for the top grills for the summer of 26 - 29, with different grill
an advertisement for the top grills for the summer of 26 - 29, with different grill
a man grilling hotdogs on an outdoor bbq with people standing around
a man grilling hotdogs on an outdoor bbq with people standing around

Charcoal Grills

Charcoal grills are lauded for producing authentic, flame-kissed flavors that gas grills simply can't match. They're also generally more affordable and require minimal assembly. However, they can be more challenging to use, as maintaining consistent temperature and cleaning the grill after use can be labor-intensive.

Charcoal grills come in different configurations, such as kettle, barrel, and smoker styles, catering to various cooking preferences and techniques.

AD

Fuel Source: Pros and Cons

In addition to the grill types, the fuel source plays a significant role in your decision-making process. Here's a concise comparison:

​​Best Gas Grills Under $500 - Consumer Reports
​​Best Gas Grills Under $500 - Consumer Reports
Everything You Need to Know About Grilling Season [infographic]
Everything You Need to Know About Grilling Season [infographic]
Derrick Riches - Barbecue & Grilling
Derrick Riches - Barbecue & Grilling
The best gas grills under $250, ranked by Consumer Reports data — TheStreet
The best gas grills under $250, ranked by Consumer Reports data — TheStreet
The ultimate guide to the grill master (Infographic)
The ultimate guide to the grill master (Infographic)
Armand's Discount Fireplace & BBQ Store | Culver City
Armand's Discount Fireplace & BBQ Store | Culver City

Propane vs. Natural Gas vs. Charcoal vs. Pellets

Propane grills offer portability and can be used where natural gas isn't available. However, their fuel tanks need to be replaced, and they can be more expensive to operate in the long run.

Natural gas grills, on the other hand, are plumbed into your home's gas line, providing an unlimited supply of fuel. They're sleek, convenient, and generally more affordable to run. But they lack portability and installation can be expensive.

AD

Charcoal grills are affordable and easy to set up. They deliver superior searing and smoking capabilities, but they're messier and harder to control than gas grills.

the side view of a green and white building with lots of shutters on it
the side view of a green and white building with lots of shutters on it

Pellet grills are a hybrid option, feeding on wood pellets to provide a unique smoky flavor. They offer programmable temperature control, but they're more expensive and require more maintenance than other grill types.

Key Features to Consider

Now that you're familiar with the various grill types and fuel sources, let's discuss essential features that can enhance your grilling experience:

AD

BTU Output and Heat Distribution

BTU (British Thermal Unit) measures the heat output of a grill. However, a high BTU doesn't necessarily translate to better performance. What's more important is how well the grill distributes heat. Look for grills with even heat distribution and built-in temperature gauges for better control.

Cooking Grates and Cooking Area

The material of the cooking grates significantly impacts the cooking process. Cast iron, stainless steel, and porcelain-enameled grates are the most common options, each with its unique benefits and drawbacks. Also, consider the total cooking area, ensuring it's sufficient for your needs.

Grill Accessories and Supertoppers

Some grills come with additional features like side burners, rotisserie kits, built-in thermometers, and warming racks. These can expand your cooking capabilities but may also jack up the price. Consider whether these extras are worth the investment.

When shopping for a grill, always read consumer reports and reviews to gauge real-world performance and durability. Consider your budget, cooking preferences, and long-term plans, and you'll be well on your way to finding the perfect grill. Happy grilling!"

AD