difference between test plan and procedure

Test Plan vs Procedure: Key Differences Explained

By Emily Harris
AD

Have you ever found yourself having to design a quality assurance strategy, or perhaps updating an existing one? If so, you might have encountered some confusion regarding the difference between a test plan and a test procedure. These two crucial components of software testing are often used interchangeably, but they serve distinct purposes. Let's delve into the intricacies of each, helping you understand how to use them effectively in your software development lifecycle.

Before we dive in, it's essential to grasp that neither of these artifacts is set in stone. Organizations may have varying interpretations, primarily depending on their specific context, methodologies, and workflows. However, we'll adhere to the commonly accepted definitions and uses as outlined in the International Software Testing Qualifications Board (ISTQB) guidelines.

Test Plan vs. Test Procedure: A High-Level Overview

At a macro level, a test plan is a comprehensive document outlining test strategies, objectives, scope, milestones, and resources required to validate your software. It's a blueprint that outlines 'what' you need to test, 'when' to test it, and 'who' will do it. On the other hand, a test procedure is a detailed description of 'how' to perform specific tests. It's a micro-level directive, providing step-by-step instructions on executing tests, verifying results, and recording data.

AD
Project Management
Project Management
Objectives test
Objectives test
Test Plan vs Test Strategy: Understanding the Difference
Test Plan vs Test Strategy: Understanding the Difference

A test plan provides a high-level view, helping stakeholders understand the testing strategy and efforts. In contrast, a test procedure offers a granular view, guiding testers in their day-to-day tasks. Think of the test plan as your roadmap, and test procedures as your GPS navigation. You need both to reach your destination – successful software testing and delivery.

Test Plan: The Big Picture

A test plan is typically developed during the test planning phase, often initiated by a test manager or a qualified test lead. It's usually created for each software release or iteration, aligning with the software development methodology, such as Agile or Waterfall. Some key sections of a test plan include:

Test Automation Vs Manual Testing: Explained!
Test Automation Vs Manual Testing: Explained!
a circular diagram showing the different stages of project management and how to use it in order to
a circular diagram showing the different stages of project management and how to use it in order to
Google Image Result for https://media.geeksforgeeks.org/wp-content/uploads/20240814125524/Test-Plan-Template-Format.webp
Google Image Result for https://media.geeksforgeeks.org/wp-content/uploads/20240814125524/Test-Plan-Template-Format.webp
  • Test items: What functionality or features to test?
  • Features to be tested: The specific attributes of the test items.
  • Test techniques: How will the tests be executed?
  • Test tasks: A breakdown of the work involved in testing.

A well-structured test plan promotes efficient use of resources, reduces risks, and ensures better test execution. However, it's less aboutspecifics and more about providing direction.

Test Plan Content: The 'What' and 'Why'

The test plan primarily focuses on what needs to be tested and why. It explains the test scope, strategy, and approach. It details the features or functionality to be tested, the test methods to be used, and the rationale behind these choices. It's a critical communication tool, sharing testing goals and methods with all stakeholders.

AD

For instance, in an e-commerce software, the test plan might include a test of the user checkout process. It would describe the intent (to ensure users can complete their purchases without issues), the scope (all stages of the checkout process), the methods (functional testing with manual and automated techniques), and the rationale (because this feature is crucial for user satisfaction and revenue generation).

What is an inspection and test plan (ITP)?
What is an inspection and test plan (ITP)?
5 Steps to Create a Test Plan for Your New Feature Release (Free test plan te... | Planio
5 Steps to Create a Test Plan for Your New Feature Release (Free test plan te... | Planio
the software testing cycle is shown in red and white, with arrows pointing to it
the software testing cycle is shown in red and white, with arrows pointing to it
Hire testing professionals who combine technical knowledge, creativity, and problem-solving to deliv
Hire testing professionals who combine technical knowledge, creativity, and problem-solving to deliv
the process diagram for testing and testing
the process diagram for testing and testing
Test Strategy Document with Sample Test Strategy Template Example
Test Strategy Document with Sample Test Strategy Template Example

Test Plan Elements: The 'When' and 'Who'

Beyond the 'what' and 'why', a test plan also outlines the 'when' and 'who'. It sets out timelines and milestones, showing when specific tests should occur. It identifies who will be involved in testing, their roles, and responsibilities. This ensures that everyone knows what's expected of them and when.

Using our e-commerce software example, the test plan might establish a test timeline, indicating that the checkout process tests will occur after the development and integration phases. It might also specify that the QA team will handle the manual tests, while the development team will take care of automated tests.

AD

Test Procedure: The Nitty-Gritty

A test procedure, on the other hand, offers a granular view. It's typically created by the testers who will execute the tests, during the test preparation phase. It's a standard operating procedure (SOP) that explains how to set up the test environment, execute test cases, observe expected results, log defects, and generate test reports.

3 Advantages Of Load Testing Your Application
3 Advantages Of Load Testing Your Application

A well-documented test procedure ensures consistent, reliable, and efficient test execution. It promotes a standardized approach, reducing human error and variability. It also facilitates knowledge sharing, enabling team members to understand and adopt best practices.

Test Procedure Components: The 'How'

A test procedure primarily provides a 'how-to' guide. It details the test environment setup, data preparation, test case execution, and result analysis. It explains how to verify the expected results, how to handle unexpected outcomes, and how to report findings.

AD

Using our e-commerce checkout process example once again, the test procedure might detail the following steps: set up the test environment, enter test data, initiate the checkout process, observe the results, compare them with the expected outcomes, log any discrepancies, and generate a test report. It might also include troubleshooting steps for common issues.

Test Procedure Template: Ensuring Consistency

Test procedures often follow a consistent template to ensure standardization and ease of use. The template may include sections for test case identification, preconditions, step-by-step test execution, expected results, actual results, pass/fail criteria, and notes. Some organizations also include a section for test environment setup, a brief test case description, or a link to related test cases or bug reports.

For instance, a test procedure template might look something like this:

Test Case ID Precondition Step 1 Expected Result Actual Result Pass/Fail
TC001 The checkout process is available. Click on 'Proceed to Checkout'. The user is directed to the shipping information page. N/A ( Execute first then fill this out) N/A

The Interdependency of Test Plans and Test Procedures

A test plan and test procedures are interdependent. The test plan provides the high-level strategy, guiding the overall testing effort. The test procedures, in turn, put that strategy into action, ensuring that tests are executed consistently and accurately. They support and reinforce each other in your testing process.

A common misconception is to think that a test plan is sufficient, and you don't need test procedures. However, without detailed test procedures, test execution can become chaotic and inconsistent. Conversely, without a test plan, test procedures lack direction and purpose. Therefore, both are critical components in your software testing arsenal.

In conclusion (without using that cliché), understanding the difference between a test plan and a test procedure is key to effective software testing. A well-thought-out test plan provides the big picture and ensures that testing efforts are goal-oriented and efficient. Robust test procedures, on the other hand, ensure that tests are executed consistently, accurately, and effectively. Together, they promote better software quality, reduced testing risks, and increased testing confidence. So go ahead, plan and execute your tests wisely – your users and your team will thank you!

AD