does insurance cover attorney fees

Does Insurance Cover Attorney Fees

By Andrew Taylor
AD

When you're faced with a legal dispute, hiring an attorney can be a crucial decision. However, the financial aspect often raises questions - does insurance cover attorney fees? Understanding your policy's coverage can help you make informed decisions. Let's delve into this question, exploring different types of insurance and their provisions for legal fees.

Insurance policies are complex, with varying coverage. We'll break down whether they cover legal fees under three main categories: personal injury and property damage liability, umbrella insurance, and specific legal expense policies.

Liability Insurance Coverage

Liability insurance, such as homeowners', auto, or business liability insurance, primarily covers damages you're legally responsible for. But what about attorney fees? Here's a closer look:

AD
How Do Contingency Fees Work in Insurance Bad Faith Cases?
How Do Contingency Fees Work in Insurance Bad Faith Cases?
a judge's gavel sitting on top of a book next to a pile of books
a judge's gavel sitting on top of a book next to a pile of books
three binders stacked on top of each other with the words, insurers are asking sharpe questions at renewal
three binders stacked on top of each other with the words, insurers are asking sharpe questions at renewal

Generally, liability insurance does not cover lawyer's fees for your defense. They typically only cover the costs of damages, settlements, or judgments awarded against you. However, there are exceptions:

Named Perils and Exclusions

Check your policy's "named perils" and "exclusions" sections. Some policies may cover legal costs if they arise from a covered peril. They might also have exclusions for certain kinds of legal action, like employment discrimination lawsuits.

What Homeowners Insurance Actually Covers: The Six Coverage Parts
What Homeowners Insurance Actually Covers: The Six Coverage Parts
How Much Umbrella Insurance Coverage Do You Need?
How Much Umbrella Insurance Coverage Do You Need?
an advertisement for a company with purple umbrellas on the front and back of it
an advertisement for a company with purple umbrellas on the front and back of it

For instance, homeowners' insurance might cover legal fees if you're sued over a dog bite under its liability coverage but exclude fees related to business activities.

Duty to Defend

Some policies, like commercial general liability insurance, have a "duty to defend" clause. This means the insurer will pay for your legal defense, up to the policy's limit, if you're sued for a covered loss.

AD

However, this typically only applies to lawsuits, not to attorney fees incurred before a lawsuit is filed. It's essential to review your policy carefully or consult with your insurer to understand your coverage fully.

a black umbrella sitting on top of a desk next to a book and calculator
a black umbrella sitting on top of a desk next to a book and calculator
What Personal Liability Insurance Covers
What Personal Liability Insurance Covers
What Happens If There Is Not Enough Insurance Coverage?
What Happens If There Is Not Enough Insurance Coverage?
What Is Ordinance or Law Coverage? | Home Insurance Explained
What Is Ordinance or Law Coverage? | Home Insurance Explained
What is the Legal Standard to Overturn an Appraisal in Florida? | Property Insurance Coverage Law Blog
What is the Legal Standard to Overturn an Appraisal in Florida? | Property Insurance Coverage Law Blog
Cover your Financial Loss with Personal Injury Lawsuit
Cover your Financial Loss with Personal Injury Lawsuit

Umbrella Insurance

Umbrella insurance is designed to provide additional liability coverage above the limits of your primary policies. But does it cover attorney fees? The short answer is: it depends.

Umbrella policies typically state that they'll cover legal defense costs "as a part of the loss we cover." Therefore, if your primary policy doesn't cover attorney fees, neither will your umbrella policy. However, if a covered peril in your primary policy mandates the use of an attorney, the umbrella policy might kick in.

AD

Excess vs. Additional Coverage

Some umbrella policies provide excess coverage, meaning they only pay if your primary liability limits are exhausted. Others offer additional coverage, which can provide some level of protection before your primary limits are reached. Review your policy to understand which type you have.

business people standing in front of a balance scale
business people standing in front of a balance scale

Umbrella policies' legal fee coverage is complex, so it's crucial to discuss your specific policy with your insurance agent or legal counsel.

Endorsements and Riders

Some insurers offer endorsements or riders that can extend your umbrella policy's coverage to include legal fees, even when other liability policies don't. These add-ons can provide valuable protection, so consider asking your insurer about them.

AD

Again, it's crucial to understand the specifics of your policy. An insurance agent or attorney can help you interpret the fine print and ensure you're properly covered.

Specific Legal Expense Insurance

Some insurance policies are specifically designed to cover legal fees. These can be particularly useful for business owners facing lawsuits or individuals involved in complex legal disputes.

Legal expense insurance, or LEX, policies typically cover attorney's fees, court costs, and other related expenses. They usually have different levels of coverage, such as:

  • Full coverage: Covers all legal costs, even when you're at fault.
  • Proportional coverage: Covers costs based on the insurer's proportion of liability.
  • European-style coverage: Covers all costs, regardless of fault, but requires you to repay a portion if you lose the case.

Review policy wording carefully, as these types of policies can have caps on coverage, deductibles, and may not cover certain types of cases or costs.

Prepaid Legal Services

Prepaid legal services are not insurance but rather a subscription service. You typically pay an annual fee to access a network of attorneys who provide various legal services for a discounted rate. These plans usually cover a wide range of legal issues, including estate planning, traffic violations, and contract review.

However, they often have caps on the number of services or hours provided, and they may not cover all types of legal situations, especially complex or high-stakes cases. Nonetheless, they can be an affordable way to access legal help for routine matters.

Understanding whether insurance covers attorney fees requires careful review of your policies and consultation with your insurer or an attorney. Every policy is unique, and coverage can vary significantly. Don't wait until you're faced with legal action to find out what's covered. Review your policies regularly and consider seeking professional advice to ensure you're adequately protected.

AD