empty subjects

Empty Subjects: The Real Question

By Amanda Lee
AD

In the realm of grammar and linguistics, the concept of empty subjects often leaves learners bewildered. Anempty subject, or expletive subject, is a grammatical element that serves no semantic purpose, merely filling the subject slot in a sentence for syntactic reasons. Let's delve into this intriguing topic, exploring its role, types, and examples.

Empty subjects play a crucial role in maintaining grammatical structure. They help to ensure that every clause begins with a subject, even when the actual subject is the object of a preposition or comes later in the sentence. This might seem odd, but this subject-initial rule is a fundamental aspect of English grammar.

Types of Empty Subjects

The most common types of empty subjects in English are 'it' and 'there'. Both serve as dummy subjects, providing a grammatical subject when no semantic subject is available.

AD
an empty classroom with desks and chairs in front of a window at sundown
an empty classroom with desks and chairs in front of a window at sundown
a lone man standing in the middle of a field at sunset or sunrise, with his back turned to the camera
a lone man standing in the middle of a field at sunset or sunrise, with his back turned to the camera
black and white photograph of empty chairs in a room with no one sitting on the chair
black and white photograph of empty chairs in a room with no one sitting on the chair

Another type is the 'invariant' or '.Null Subject', where the subject slot is left empty, most commonly in questions and inversions. This is more common in languages like Spanish, but we'll explore its use in English as well.

Expletive 'It'

Expletive 'it' is used when the actual subject doesn't come first, usually because it's the object of a preposition or a relative clause. For instance, 'It's raining' is a classic example, where 'it' is the empty subject, and the actual subject is 'raining'.

a woman is standing in an empty room
a woman is standing in an empty room
an empty chair floating in the ocean on top of water with waves coming up around it
an empty chair floating in the ocean on top of water with waves coming up around it
an empty subway station with stairs and tiled floors
an empty subway station with stairs and tiled floors

Similarly, 'It was successful' uses 'it' as the subject, with the actual subject being the object 'it' refers to - the thing that was successful.

'There' as an Empty Subject

'There' can function as an empty subject, often introducing a sentence with a presentational function. For example, 'There is a cat on the mat' presents a new piece of information, with 'there' being the empty subject, and 'a cat on the mat' being the sentence's focus.

AD

'There' can also be used with passive constructions, as in 'There were three CVs left on the table'. Here, 'there' is the subject, and 'three CVs' is the object, having the focus of the sentence.

an empty room with two chairs in the corner and sunlight coming through the windows on the wall
an empty room with two chairs in the corner and sunlight coming through the windows on the wall
a woman sitting on a chair in an empty room looking out the window at something
a woman sitting on a chair in an empty room looking out the window at something
unknown
unknown
Result...
Result...
They never found out where I went.
They never found out where I went.
a person sitting on a chair in an empty room with rows of chairs lined up against the wall
a person sitting on a chair in an empty room with rows of chairs lined up against the wall

Empty Subjects in Questions and Inversions

In questions and inversions, the subject slot can be left empty. For instance, 'Was it raining?' Here, 'it' is not an expletive subject but a pronoun. The empty subject position is left unsaid due to the structure of the question.

In inversions, like 'Hardly had I finished when she arrived', the subject 'I' is postponed, leaving an empty subject position at the start of the sentence.

AD

Invariant 'there' in English

While not as common as in Spanish or other Romance languages, English also uses an invariant 'there' with no explicit subject. For example, 'There goes John' can be used to indicate John's arrival or departure.

This usage of 'there' is more situational and context-dependent, often indicating a change of state or a sudden appearance, as in 'There's the book I've been looking for!'

Understanding empty subjects is crucial for comprehending English grammar. They might seem puzzling at first, but with patience and practice, they become intuitive. So, the next time you hear 'It's raining' or 'There you are', recognize the power of these empty subjects keeping our language smooth and structured.

AD
AD