form validation error message

Form Validation Error Messages: Fix & Prevent in 2023

By Joseph Jones
AD

Ever filled out a web form only to find that you've missed a field or entered invalid data? That's where form validation error messages come into play. They're part of what makes the digital user experience more intuitive and forgiving. But designing them effectively isn't always straightforward. Let's delve into the world of form validation error messages and explore best practices to ensure they're useful, not intrusive.

Before we dive in, let's agree on one thing: form validation error messages are crucial. They provide immediate feedback to users, helping them understand what they've done wrong and how to fix it. But done poorly, they can also frustrate users and disrupt workflows. So how can we get them right?

Understanding the Basics of Form Validation Error Messages

At their core, form validation error messages serve two primary purposes: to inform and to guide. They need to tell the user what went wrong and guide them on how to correct their mistake.

AD
The Ultimate UX Design of Form Validation
The Ultimate UX Design of Form Validation
the sign up page for an email account is shown in this screenshote image
the sign up page for an email account is shown in this screenshote image
Form validation best practices
Form validation best practices

To achieve this, error messages should be:

  • Concise and clear
  • Placed next to the field they’re referring to
  • Displayed immediately after the user makes an error
  • Written in simple, easy-to-understand language

Being Clear and Concise

Clarity is king when it comes to error messages. They should clearly state what the issue is and how to resolve it. Vague messages like "Invalid input" only confuse users. Instead, consider something like: "Please enter a valid email address. It should look something like name@example.com."

Simple jQuery Form Validation
Simple jQuery Form Validation
an email form is shown in red, white and blue with the words'do not enter
an email form is shown in red, white and blue with the words'do not enter
an email form is shown on the screen for someone to log in and receive their phone number
an email form is shown on the screen for someone to log in and receive their phone number

But remember, brevity is also key. Long, wordy messages can distract from the main task. Keep them short, usually no more than one or two lines of text.

Placement Matters

Error messages should always appear close to the field they're referring to. This helps users quickly identify and understand where they went wrong. Ideally, they should appear directly below or next to the field, not at the top of the page.

AD

In some cases, you might need to use a combination of inline (next to the field) and summary (at the top of the page) errors, but this should be a last resort. The goal is to keep users focused on the task at hand, not distract them with lots of red text scattered across the page.

the sign up page for an email form that is being used to log into your account
the sign up page for an email form that is being used to log into your account
the user's login screen is shown in this screenshote, and it appears to be filled with information
the user's login screen is shown in this screenshote, and it appears to be filled with information
Forms Need Validation
Forms Need Validation
How to Improve Validation Errors – Baymard Institute
How to Improve Validation Errors – Baymard Institute
Why Users Make More Errors with Instant Inline Validation
Why Users Make More Errors with Instant Inline Validation
an image of the web page for someone's blog or website that has been blocked
an image of the web page for someone's blog or website that has been blocked

Crafting Effective Error Message Copy

Good error messages don't just inform, they guide. They should tell users exactly what they need to do to fix the problem.

But how you frame that guidance is also important. It's not just about telling users what they did wrong, it's about helping them understand how to do it right.

AD

Positive Language

Rather than pointing out what's wrong, try to focus on what the user should do. Instead of saying "Invalid ZIP code", consider something like: "Please enter a ZIP code. It should be five digits, like 12345." This tells the user what they need to do and how to do it, making the error message more actionable.

the words form validation using php are shown in blue letters on a white background
the words form validation using php are shown in blue letters on a white background

Where possible, use positive language. Instead of saying "Error: This field is required", try "Please enter a value for this field." It might seem like a small change, but it can make a big difference in how users perceive the error.

Personalization

Sometimes, a little personalization can go a long way in making error messages more helpful. Instead of saying "password too short", consider something like: "Hi Alex, your password needs to be at least 8 characters long. Try adding a few more characters." This approach makes the message feel more personal, and can make it easier for users to understand what's expected.

AD

But be careful with this. Over-personalization can feel creepy or intrusive. Never use any sensitive or private information, and never make the user feel self-conscious about their mistakes.

Testing and Iterating Your Error Messages

Writing good error messages isn't a set-it-and-forget-it task. They should be tested and iterated just like any other part of your user interface.

/User testing is an invaluable tool here. Watching real users interact with your forms can provide insights you might not have considered. It can highlight confusion, frustration, or errors in understanding that you can then address with revised error messages.

Regular Reviews

Also, regular reviews of your error messages can help ensure they're still relevant and useful. As your application evolves, so might your validation rules and user expectations. Make sure your error messages are keeping up.

Additionally, consider using analytics to monitor how users interact with your form validation error messages. If certain messages are causing high bounce rates or a lot of user confusion, they might need revision.

In the ever-evolving world of user experience design, there's always more to learn and improve. But with a focus on clarity, brevity, and user-centric design, you can craft form validation error messages that inform, guide, and support your users in their task, rather than confusing or frustrating them. And isn't that the ultimate goal of any good user experience?

AD