goat format ban list

The Ultimate Goat Format Ban List

By John Wilson
AD

The goat format, or ">=3" ranking system, has seen a surge in popularity, especially within gaming and achievement communities. Loved for its leniency and inclusivity, it's a scoring metric that awards a positive score for any attempt, no matter how small. Yet, like any system, it has its critics and certain formats have been met with disapproval, leading to the development of a "ban list".

This guide delves into the goat format ban list, explaining what it is, why it exists, and the key formats it lists. Understanding these criteria can help you navigate the goat format's nuances and remain in the good graces of its community.

The Genesis of the Goat Format Ban List

The goat format ban list emerged from the desire to maintain the spirit of the goat format while addressing certain exploitations and uncontrolled aspects. It aims to encourage genuine, meaningful attempts while discouraging inflated or false scores.

AD
Recordkeeping on the Homestead: Goat Records
Recordkeeping on the Homestead: Goat Records
Record Keeping for Goats
Record Keeping for Goats
+20 Goat Record Keeping Template
+20 Goat Record Keeping Template

Coined by the gaming community, the ban list is not an official rulebook, but rather a widely accepted set of guidelines. Adhering to these guidelines shows respect for the format's core principles and fosters a positive, fair gaming spirit.

Understanding the 100% Rule

The 100% rule, or the "no score inflation" rule, is the cornerstone of the goat format ban list. It states that any percentage score above 100% should be denied, regardless of the endeavor's authenticity or difficulty. This rule prevents inflating scores by manipulating time limits or using excessive attempts to achieve a score beyond 100%.

Dairy Goat Show Packing List
Dairy Goat Show Packing List
an image of a page with text on it
an image of a page with text on it
an image of goat breeds in different states of the world, including goats and sheeps
an image of goat breeds in different states of the world, including goats and sheeps

For instance, in a platformer game with a time limit, beating the game in half the time allowed does not warrant a 150% score. Instead, it's counted as a 100% completion with a time bonus achievement tacked on.

Banning "No Death" or "Perfect" Runs

The ban list also targets "no death" or "perfect" runs, where beating a game without dying secures a higher score. Critics argue that this encourages risk-averse gameplay, neglecting the fun and challenge in favor of minute precision. It also advantages cautious playstyles over aggressive ones.

AD

A game beaten without dying should earn the same goat score as one beaten with a single death. While perfect runs are impressive, they should not be rewarded with a higher score in the goat format.

an animal chart with all the different breeds and their names in english, spanish, and german
an animal chart with all the different breeds and their names in english, spanish, and german
different types of goats and their names are shown in this chart, which shows the various breeds
different types of goats and their names are shown in this chart, which shows the various breeds
an image of a goat with different colors on it's face and the diagram below
an image of a goat with different colors on it's face and the diagram below
Common Goat Breeds
Common Goat Breeds
Record Keeping for Goats
Record Keeping for Goats
a poster with different types of cows on it's sides and the words identification signs of different goat diseases
a poster with different types of cows on it's sides and the words identification signs of different goat diseases

Key Formats Affected by the Ban List

The ban list particularly influences speedruns and games with alternative paths or endings. Let's explore these formats and their relationship with the ban list.

While speedruns typically involve shaving off seconds to achieve the fastest time, they're not immune to the 100% rule. A speedrun that takes 50% of the game's timer is scored as a 100% completion, not 50%, to discourage excessive score inflation.

AD

Games with Multiple Endings

The goat format ban list discourages awarding extra points for completing 'hidden' or 'alternative' ending routes. While these extra endings might add replayability, they don't represent 'deeper' completion if the main story route is already beaten.

a printable dog grooming planner is shown in this image, it shows the daily schedule
a printable dog grooming planner is shown in this image, it shows the daily schedule

For example, a game with 10 different endings shouldn't award anything more than a 100% score after all endings are seen. The goat format encourages completion over trivial pursuits.

Games with User-Generated Content

Some games, like littleBigPlanet or Super Mario Maker, allow users to create their own levels. While these can be creative and challenging, the goat format ban list discourages awarding scores for clearing user-generated content (UGC) alone.

AD

UGC must be used in conjunction with an official level or an equally widespread user-created challenge. Awarding scores for clearing user-generated levels on their own can lead to inflation and game the system.">

Avoiding these banned formats helps maintain the spirit of the goat format, encouraging genuine play and completion over false inflation. Always remember, the goal is inclusive, positive scoring, not militantly pursuing a perfect 100%."

AD