harlequin ends historical romance

Harlequin Ends Era of Historical Romance

By Ashley Lewis
AD

The publishing world has been abuzz with news that Harlequin, the powerhouse of romance novels, is bidding farewell to its historical romance line. For decades, Harlequin has captivated readers with its jaw-dropping dukes, swashbuckling pirates, and irresistible cowboys, each wearing a different historical era's fashion. But why this sudden exit from a beloved genre?

Harlequin's decision, announced in late 2021, has sparked much debate among readers, authors, and industry insiders. The company cited a shift in reader preferences and a desire to focus on other successful lines, such as contemporary romance and romantic suspense. But what does this mean for historical romance lovers, and where can they find their hade of Regency-era swoons and American Wild West exploits?

The Shift in Reader Preferences

Harlequin's move is not an isolated incident. The publishing industry is witnessing a wider trend of readers shifting their tastes towards more diverse and contemporary stories. According to a 2021 survey by the Romance Writers of America, readers are increasingly seeking narratives that reflect their own experiences and the broader world around them.

AD
HH-2. Jul-1986 Harlequin
HH-2. Jul-1986 Harlequin
Harlequin Historical Romance Collection - Lot of 6 Romance Paperbacks
Harlequin Historical Romance Collection - Lot of 6 Romance Paperbacks
Love Alters Not (Harlequin Romance, #1191)
Love Alters Not (Harlequin Romance, #1191)

This preference shift, accelerated by the global pandemic, has led to an explosion in the popularity of COVID-era sub-genres like 'PNR' (paranormal romance), 'MF' (male/female romance with polyamory), and 'OTT' (over-the-top romances). These genres offer readers a chance to escape into fantastical worlds or explore taboo scenarios, making historical romance's period-bound settings and societal norms feel somewhat restrictive.

What's Driving the Trend?

One reason for this reader preference shift is the increasing diversity of media consumption. With streaming services and podcasts offering a vast array of stories, readers are exposed to a wider range of narratives and perspectives. Additionally, social media and targeted online advertising algorithms expose readers to a more diverse set of genres and authors, luring them away from traditional romance staples.

Historical Romance Books Will Be Discontinued by Major Publisher After Nearly 40 Years
Historical Romance Books Will Be Discontinued by Major Publisher After Nearly 40 Years
Harlequin Mills & Boon; (March 4, 2005)
Harlequin Mills & Boon; (March 4, 2005)
Northern Sunset
Northern Sunset

Another factor driving the trend is the wealth of newer, fresh voices in the romance genre. Many of these authors approach romantic storytelling with fresh perspectives, tackling issues like representation, diversity, and toxic relationships head-on. For readers seeking complex, emotionally resonant stories, these newer authors offer a compelling alternative to traditional historical romance.

Historical Romance's Future: Not Unchanged, But Evolving

While Harlequin's announcement has cast a cloud of uncertainty over historical romance's future, many industry experts maintain that the genre is not disappearing, but rather, evolving. Avid readers and authors are finding new ways to sate their historical cravings, with indie publishing and online communities stepping in to fill the void left by Harlequin.

AD

Historical romance readers on social media platforms like Twitter and Goodreads are banding together, using hashtags like #HistoricalRomanceTwitter and #HistoricalRomanceRecommend to discover and recommend their favorite historical romance authors and books. Meanwhile, authors are finding success by self-publishing or signing with smaller presses, allowing them to reach readers directly.

HH-5. Sep-1986 Harlequin
HH-5. Sep-1986 Harlequin
HH-85 HR Jul-1991
HH-85 HR Jul-1991
the cover of barbara cartland's cupid rides pillon, with an image of
the cover of barbara cartland's cupid rides pillon, with an image of
the perfect wife by mary burton
the perfect wife by mary burton
many dvd's are stacked on top of each other in order to be read
many dvd's are stacked on top of each other in order to be read
Harlequin Presents Romance Novel | Vintage 1980s Lot of 5 Paperback Love Stories Collectible Set
Harlequin Presents Romance Novel | Vintage 1980s Lot of 5 Paperback Love Stories Collectible Set

Indie Publishing: A New Frontier for Historical Romance

With traditional publishing houses like Harlequin focusing on other genres, indie authors are seizing the opportunity to publish historical romance. Platforms like Amazon KDP, Draft2Digital, and IngramSpark make it easier than ever for authors to publish and distribute their books. Moreover, online marketplaces and social media allow indie authors to reach readers directly, building a loyal community around their work.

Take authoregenievade, for instance. After struggling to find a publisher for her historical romance novel, she decided to self-publish on Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP). To her surprise, her book, "The Duke's Surrender," became an instant hit, reaching the #1 spot in Amazon's Historical Regency Romance category within a week of release and earning her a five-figure advance from a traditional publisher.

AD

Ceaslessly Evolving: Nove Historical Romance Sub-genres

Another way historical romance is evolving is through the emergence of new sub-genres. Authors are pushing the boundaries of historical romance by blending it with other genres, resulting in fresh, innovative stories. Some examples include 'historical paranormal,' which infuses elements of the supernatural into historical settings, and 'reverse harem,' which explores themes of polyamory in historical contexts.

Harlequin Regency - 70, Mar-1992
Harlequin Regency - 70, Mar-1992

Additionally, authors are expanding the historical romance timeline to explore less-familiar eras and cultures. For instance, 'Pablemente Historical Romance' focuses on storytelling inspired by pre-Columbian Mesoamerican history, while 'Egyptian Historical Romance' delves into the dramatic love stories of ancient Egypt. As readers seek out original and diverse stories, these emerging sub-genres present exciting opportunities for both authors and readers.

Despite Harlequin's exit, historical romance is far from extinct. Instead, it's transforming, adapting to the changing preferences and needs of its dedicated readership. While the future of historical romance may not look like its past, it's an exciting time for readers eager to explore new authors, publishers, and sub-genres that promise to keep the genre alive and thriving.

AD
AD