St. Louis vs. Kansas City: Which is Bigger?
When it comes to the metropolises of Missouri, St. Louis and Kansas City, each city has its unique charm and historical significance. But when it comes to size, who takes the crown? Let's delve into the demographics and geographical aspects to determine if St. Louis (STL) or Kansas City (KC) is bigger.
At the outset, it's essential to understand that there's no definitive answer to this question, as 'bigger' can refer to various aspects, including population, land area, or cultural influence. Let's explore each city's size from these perspectives.
Population Size
The most straightforward way to compare the two cities is by their population size. According to the 2020 U.S. Census, Kansas City has a slightly larger population than St. Louis. On average, KC's population is around 491,918, compared to the 301,578 residents in STL.
However, it's worth noting that the metropolitan area (or metropolitan statistical area, MSA) provides a more comprehensive picture of a city's size and influence. When considering the Kansas City metro area, the population jumps to over 2 million, making it the largest MSA in Missouri. Meanwhile, the St. Louis MSA has a population of approximately 2.8 million, making it the largest in the state.
City Proper vs. MSA
When comparing the cities based solely on their central cities' populations, Kansas City comes out ahead. However, when including their surrounding metro areas, St. Louis gains the upper hand in terms of population. This difference can be attributed, in part, to St. Louis' annexation policies in the early 20th century, which expanded its municipal boundaries significantly.
Furthermore, the expansion of STL's suburbs has led to a more decentralized growth pattern, with population growth occurring primarily in the outlying counties. This trend has made the St. Louis region more sprawling and less dense than its northern counterpart.
City Population Density
While Kansas City has a larger city proper population, St. Louis is more densely populated, with about 1,600 people per square mile compared to KC's approximately 1,200 people per square mile. This difference in density contributes to the distinct urban characteristics of the two cities.
St. Louis, with its higher population density, has a more urban feel, with taller buildings and busier streets. In contrast, Kansas City's lower density creates a more spread-out, suburban atmosphere, with a mix of green spaces and urban development.
Land Area Size
If we consider land area, Kansas City is the larger of the two cities, with around 315.8 square miles, while St. Louis covers about 66.2 square miles. However, it's crucial to note that these figures represent only the central cities' land areas and not their entire metro regions.
The combined land area of the Kansas City and St. Louis MSAs is much more similar, with the Kansas City MSA covering about 4,700 square miles and the St. Louis MSA spanning around 6,300 square miles. This difference is mainly due to St. Louis' larger, more sprawling urban footprint.
Geographic Expansion
St. Louis' historic annexations, mentioned earlier, not only expanded its population but also increased its geographic footprint. Today, STL encompasses various neighborhoods, from the urban core to the suburbs. In contrast, Kansas City's geographic expansion has been more modest, with most of its growth occurring within the central city rather than through annexation.
In terms of both population and land area, the two cities have distinct characteristics that shape their size and influence. While Kansas City has a larger central city population and land area, St. Louis' metro region is both more densely populated and sprawling. Both cities have unique qualities that contribute to their overall size and significance in Missouri and beyond.
Ultimately, the debate over whether St. Louis or Kansas City is bigger may not have a clear-cut answer, as it depends on the specific metric you're using to define 'bigger.' Perhaps the most accurate way to frame this comparison is to appreciate the unique aspects of each city and acknowledge that both play crucial roles in shaping Missouri's cultural, economic, and demographic landscapes.