logical fallacies movie

Logical Fallacies in Film: movies that make us cringe

By Emily Jones
AD

In the world of cinema, movies often employ persuasive techniques to drive their narratives and engage audiences. One such technique is the use of logical fallacies, which can enhance storytelling by creating compelling arguments, sparking debate, or even highlighting the flaws in a character's reasoning. Let's delve into the cinematic landscape to explore some common logical fallacies and how they're masterfully used in movies.

Logical fallacies are common pitfalls in arguments and reasoning that can undermine the logic of an argument. They can be used in movies not just to create plot twists or flawed characters but also to stir emotion, add tension, or even question the reliability of information presented.

Ad Hominem Fallacy in Movies

One of the most prevalent logical fallacies in movies is Ad Hominem, where an argument's soundness is questioned based on the person making the argument, rather than the argument itself.

AD
a poster with the words, watch out for these 11 local fallacys on it
a poster with the words, watch out for these 11 local fallacys on it
Logical Fallacies
Logical Fallacies
the comic strip shows people talking to each other
the comic strip shows people talking to each other

A classic example of this can be seen in "12 Angry Men" (1957). Early in the movie, Juror #10, played by Edward Binns, dismisses Juror #8's (Henry Fonda) doubts about the defendant's guilt based on his personality: "You're a lonely little man, and you're trying to make yourself important." Here, Juror #10 attacks Juror #8's character instead of addressing his arguments, demonstrating a clear Ad Hominem fallacy.

Personal Attack

A more recent example can be found in "Les Misérables" (2012). When Javert (Russell Crowe) believes he's found Marius (Eddie Redmayne), he sings, "You're pathetic, Marius... Nothing can save you from me." Instead of engaging with Marius' actions or arguments, Javert resorts to a personal attack, employing an Ad Hominem fallacy.

Straw Man Fallacy
Straw Man Fallacy
THE LOGICAL FALLACIES
THE LOGICAL FALLACIES
8 Logical Fallacies That Are Ruining Your Arguments | Media Literacy Cheat Sheet
8 Logical Fallacies That Are Ruining Your Arguments | Media Literacy Cheat Sheet

Ironically, Javert's personal attacks reveal his own flaws and bias, adding depth to his character, and driving the plot by causing Marius to evade him.

Name-Calling

"The West Wing" (TV series, 1999-2006) also employs Ad Hominem fallacies, often in political debates. In one episode, Toby Ziegler (Richard Schiff) dismisses a constituent's complaint with, "Well, you know what? You're a moron." Here, Toby resorts to name-calling rather than engaging with the constituent's argument, demonstrating an Ad Hominem fallacy.

AD

The use of Ad Hominem fallacies in these movies and TV shows often serves to show the weakness or prejudice of the character employing it, while driving the plot forward.

Logical Fallacies
Logical Fallacies
Common Logical Fallacies Explained – Critical Thinking Classroom Poster
Common Logical Fallacies Explained – Critical Thinking Classroom Poster
an info sheet with different types of facial features and their corresponding names in red, brown and
an info sheet with different types of facial features and their corresponding names in red, brown and
Presentation: Mean Girls Logical Fallacies
Presentation: Mean Girls Logical Fallacies
Logical fallacies
Logical fallacies
the fallacy files anatomy of long - tailed falsities
the fallacy files anatomy of long - tailed falsities

Strawman Argument in Film Storytelling

Another common logical fallacy in movies is the Strawman Argument, where a person distorts, exaggerates, or misrepresents an opponent's argument to make it easier to attack.

A notable example is seen in "The Great Dictator" (1940). Charlie Chaplin's Jew Barber loses his memory and is taken for the dictator Hynkel. In one scene, Hynkel gives a speech criticizing Jews, but the Barber, believing Hynkel to be folie accès, criticizes the speech's absurdity. This is a Strawman Argument, as Hynkel's real arguments were never presented, only a spoof.

AD

Mislabeled Argument

In "The Truman Show" (1998), protagonist Truman Burbank (Jim Carrey) believes his entire life is a game show. His mentor, Christof (Ed Harris), argues that Truman is nothing more than a product. Christof mislabels Truman's claim that his life is a game show as a belief that it's a TV show, and then attacks that mislabeled argument.

Logical Fallacies: Fallacies of Relevance and Fallacies of Insufficient Evidence
Logical Fallacies: Fallacies of Relevance and Fallacies of Insufficient Evidence

Christof's argument is a Strawman, as Truman's original claim was never addressed. This fallacy drives the plot by highlighting the divide between Truman's reality and the spectacle his life has become.

Understanding and recognizing logical fallacies in movies can significantly enhance our viewing experience. It can deepen our understanding of characters, reveal subtext in plots, and even challenge our own biases and prejudices. So, the next time you watch a movie, keep an eye out for these fallacies – they might just add a whole new dimension to your enjoyment.

AD
AD