macaron america's test kitchen

Macaron Recipe: America's Test Kitchen's Delicious Twist

By Anthony Jackson
AD

Crafting the perfect macaron is an art that has long been mastered by pâtissiers in France, but what about in the United States? America's Test Kitchen, known for its rigorous testing and analysis of recipes, decided to tackle the macaron challenge head-on.

Macarons, with their delicate shells and creamy ganache, are notoriously tricky to make. From folding the batter to the crucial oven temperature, even a slight error can lead to a disappointing result. So, how did America's Test Kitchen approach this culinary conundrum?

The Quest for the Perfect Macaron Recipe

The test kitchen began by examining traditional French macaron recipes, paying close attention to ingredients, technique, and baking conditions. They quickly discovered that the French method, relying heavily on intuition and practice, wasn't yielding consistent results in their American kitchens.

AD
The Ultimate Guide to Making Macarons | America's Test Kitchen
The Ultimate Guide to Making Macarons | America's Test Kitchen
Macarons with Coffee Buttercream | America's Test Kitchen
Macarons with Coffee Buttercream | America's Test Kitchen
Macarons with Semisweet Chocolate Ganache | America's Test Kitchen
Macarons with Semisweet Chocolate Ganache | America's Test Kitchen

So, they set out to scientifically deconstruct the macaron-making process, applying their signature methodical approach to determine what truly matters in a perfect macaron recipe.

Ingredient Dissection

America's Test Kitchen started by scrutinizing the role of each ingredient. They found that almond flour, instead of all-purpose flour, was crucial for achieving the perfect texture. They also determined that granulated sugar provided better results than powdered sugar due to its ability to crystalize upon baking.

The Ultimate Guide to Making Macarons | America's Test Kitchen
The Ultimate Guide to Making Macarons | America's Test Kitchen
Macarons with Peanut Butter Cream and Jam | America's Test Kitchen
Macarons with Peanut Butter Cream and Jam | America's Test Kitchen
an article about french - style macaroons is featured in the cook's manual
an article about french - style macaroons is featured in the cook's manual

The test kitchen also replaced traditional confectioners' sugar with a mixture of granulated sugar and cornstarch for the meringue, resulting in a more stable structure for the macarons.

The Significance of Fold

One of the most debated aspects of macaron making is whether to fold the batter using the 'macaronage' technique or to pipe the batter directly. America's Test Kitchen found that folding the batter was indeed crucial in developing the structure and the all-important "beaked" macaron feet.

AD

However, they also discovered that overfolding the batter could result in a dense, discouraging macaron. They developed a precise technique for folding the batter, ensuring that just the right amount of air was incorporated for optimal results.

Macarons with Passion Fruit Curd | America's Test Kitchen
Macarons with Passion Fruit Curd | America's Test Kitchen
The Ultimate Guide to Making Macarons | America's Test Kitchen
The Ultimate Guide to Making Macarons | America's Test Kitchen
Dea Macarons - Melhor Macaron de Porto Alegre - Revista Sabores do Sul
Dea Macarons - Melhor Macaron de Porto Alegre - Revista Sabores do Sul
a man in an apron is making macaroni and cheese bites
a man in an apron is making macaroni and cheese bites
pink macaroons are on a plate with plates in the backgrouf
pink macaroons are on a plate with plates in the backgrouf
5 Easy Macaroon Recipes: Step-by-Step Guide with Ingredients, Measurements
5 Easy Macaroon Recipes: Step-by-Step Guide with Ingredients, Measurements

Baking for Excellence

After perfecting the batter, the test kitchen turned their attention to the oven. Temperature, humidity, and even altitude can significantly impact macaron baking. They found that a consistent oven temperature, around 300°F, was vital.

They also advocated for using an oven thermometer to ensure accuracy, as many home ovens can vary by as much as 50°F.

AD

Resting Time

The test kitchen acknowledged the importance of resting time for macarons. Resting allows the batter to form a skin, which holds its shape during baking. They found that resting macarons for about 30 minutes to an hour before baking ensured a consistent rise and prevented the macarons from stick to the parchment paper.

Coconut Macaroons with Chocolate Chips and Almonds | America's Test Kitchen
Coconut Macaroons with Chocolate Chips and Almonds | America's Test Kitchen

Moreover, they suggested experimenting with the resting time to understand how your kitchen's environment affects the macarons.

The Role of Humidity

Humidity can have a significant impact on macaron baking. High humidity can cause the meringue to over-absorb moisture, resulting in macarons that crack instead of rising. Similarly, low humidity can lead to macarons that don't rise at all.

AD

America's Test Kitchen advised using a dehumidifier to control the humidity levels in your workspace. Alternatively, using a kitchen torch to lightly heat the shells before filling can also help drive off excess moisture.

America's Test Kitchen concluded their macaron endeavour by developing a foolproof, scientifically-backed recipe that yields consistent, exquisite results. With their methodical approach and attention to detail, they proved that everyone, not just French pâtissiers, can master the art of the macaron. So, why not give it a try in your own American kitchen?

AD