madeleine thien do not say we have nothing review

Madeleine Thien's "Do Not Say We Have Nothing" Unveiled: A Review

By William Jackson
AD

Madeleine Thien's "Do Not Say We Have Nothing" is a gripping novel that traverses continents and generations, masterfully weaving together historical events with the intimate lives of its characters. The book was shortlisted for the Man Booker Prize in 2016 and has since garnered critical acclaim for its profound exploration of memory, identity, and the power of music.

At its heart, "Do Not Say We Have Nothing" is a story about stories, about the narratives we tell ourselves and others to understand our past and navigate our present. It is a deeply human book, one that reminds us of the resilience of the human spirit in the face of trauma and adversity.

Bildungsroman of a musician

Thien's novel is, in many ways, abildungsroman, a coming-of-age story centered around the life of Jiang Kai, a composer who grows up in China during the tumultuous 20th century. Kai's life is marked by pivotal political events, from the Cultural Revolution to the Tiananmen Square protests, but Thien's focus is less on these historical events themselves and more on how they shape Kai's artistic journey and his relationship with his family.

AD
50 of the Best Books of 2016
50 of the Best Books of 2016
Do Not Say We Have Nothing: A Novel
Do Not Say We Have Nothing: A Novel
the book cover for do not say we have nothing by madeleine thieln, which is
the book cover for do not say we have nothing by madeleine thieln, which is

Kai's story is intertwined with that of his friend, Sparrow, a violinist whose life takes a starkly different trajectory due to his family's political connections. Through Kai and Sparrow, Thien explores the complexities of artistic expression, the challenges of maintaining one's creative integrity in the face of political suppression, and the transformative power of musical education.

The role of memory and storytelling

One of the novel's most resounding themes is the role of memory and storytelling in shaping our understanding of the past. Thien masterfully employs a narrative structure that mirrors musical composition, with recurring motifs and variations that gradually cohere into a richer, more complex whole. This structure prompts readers to engage actively with the text, piecing together the puzzle of events as they unfold across time and place.

the book cover for do not say we have nothing by madeleine thien with an image of a bird on it
the book cover for do not say we have nothing by madeleine thien with an image of a bird on it
a woman with long black hair standing in front of a blue wall and looking at the camera
a woman with long black hair standing in front of a blue wall and looking at the camera
the book do not say we have nothing by madeleine thien is on display
the book do not say we have nothing by madeleine thien is on display

The novel is also a profound meditation on the power of memory, both individual and collective. Thien suggests that memory is not a fixed, objective reality, but a subjective, malleable construct. Through her characters' fragmented and incomplete recollections, she invites readers to consider the implications of this for our understanding of history and our ability to reckon with the past.

Trauma and resilience

Thien does not shy away from the horrors of political persecution, forced labor camps, and other forms of violence that characterized the 20th century in China. Yet, despite these grim realities, "Do Not Say We Have Nothing" is ultimately a story about resilience. It is about the way in which human beings, even in the face of unimaginable hardship, can find solace in art, love, and community.

AD

Thien's characters are flawed and complex, and their resilience is not some facile, inspirational cliché. Instead, it is rooted in their ability to acknowledge and process their pain, to find meaning and expression for it in their art and relationships. This is perhaps the novel's most profound lesson: that even in the darkest of times, there is always the possibility for redemption, for healing, and for hope.

an image of a quote from the book sometimes, i think you can look at a person and know they are full of words
an image of a quote from the book sometimes, i think you can look at a person and know they are full of words
Briefly Noted Book Reviews
Briefly Noted Book Reviews
the cover for do not say we have nothing by madeleine thien, with red background
the cover for do not say we have nothing by madeleine thien, with red background
the book do not say we have nothing
the book do not say we have nothing
From the archive: Review of Madeleine Thien's Dogs at the Perimeter
From the archive: Review of Madeleine Thien's Dogs at the Perimeter
Madeleine Thien Chinese History, Queen Mother, Alternate History, First Novel, Book Awards, Literary Criticism, Short Stories, The Globe, Madeleine
Madeleine Thien Chinese History, Queen Mother, Alternate History, First Novel, Book Awards, Literary Criticism, Short Stories, The Globe, Madeleine

The musical legacy of "Do Not Say We Have Nothing"

Music is a maiden of sorts in "Do Not Say We Have Nothing." It is the medium through which Thien's characters express their deepest emotions, their hopes and fears, their joys and sorrows. The novel is a love letter to classical music, particularly the works of Bach, Mahler, and Schoenberg, but it is also a meditation on music's role in society and politics.

Thien explores how music can be both a personal expression and a form of collective resistance. In some of the novel's most poignant scenes, characters find solace in music even as they are subjected to political persecution. Yet, Thien also shows how music can be co-opted by political ideologies, its power to inspire and uplift twisted and manipulated for nefarious ends.

AD

Music as a political tool

During the Cultural Revolution, the Communist Party's leaders promoted revolutionary music as a means of instilling loyalty and encouraging collective action. Thien's characters must navigate this complex political landscape, deciding whether to assimilate or rebel, to comply or resist. Through their struggles, Thien raises critical questions about the role of art in society, the tension between personal expression and political conformity.

Do Not Say We Have Nothing by Madeleine Thien – review
Do Not Say We Have Nothing by Madeleine Thien – review

Yet, even in the most repressive political climates, Thien suggests that music maintains a power that no dictator can suppress. It can be a weapon of subversion, a secret language shared among friends, a source of hope and inspiration even in the darkest of times.

Music and identity

For many of Thien's characters, music also plays a crucial role in the formation of their identities. Kai, in particular, is deeply shaped by his musical education, his love for Bach and Mahler infusing his life with meaning and purpose. Yet, Thien also shows how music can become a site of conflict and division, as characters struggle to reconcile their personal musical tastes with the expectations of their communities and societies.

AD

Ultimately, Thien suggests that music, like identity itself, is a dynamic and evolving thing. It is never fixed or static, but always changing, always growing, always capable of surprising us with its beauty and power.

In the final analysis, "Do Not Say We Have Nothing" is a testament to the enduring power of art and love in the face of adversity. It is a novel that reminds us of the importance of storytelling, of preserving our histories and sharing our memories, even as we look towards the future. It is a call to action, to engage with the world around us, to bear witness to the stories of others, and to find our own voices in the chorus of human experience. Pick up a copy of "Do Not Say We Have Nothing" and let yourself be swept up in its powerful, resonant melody.

AD