microsoft planner vs smartsheet

Microsoft Planner vs Smartsheet: The Ultimate Project Management Showdown

By Sarah Thomas
AD

When it comes to streamlining productivity and project management, two popular tools often come into the spotlight: Microsoft Planner and Smartsheet. Both offer robust features to help teams stay organized and on track, but they cater to slightly different user needs. This article delves into a detailed comparison of Microsoft Planner vs Smartsheet to help you make an informed decision.

Microsoft Planner is a visually engaging task management app that's well-integrated with the Microsoft 365 suite. It's known for its intuitive, user-friendly interface, making it an excellent choice for teams new to project management tools. On the other hand, Smartsheet is a powerful work management platform that offers a blend of traditional Gantt charts and modern project management capabilities, catering to both new and experienced project managers.

Interface and Ease of Use

Planner's user interface is clean, colorful, and highly visual, with a card-based design that makes tasks easy to scan and understand. It's particularly popular among teams that appreciate visual cues and want a quick, intuitive overview of their projects.

AD
What is Microsoft Planner?
What is Microsoft Planner?
Microsoft Planner vs. Tasks Web Part | SharePoint Maven
Microsoft Planner vs. Tasks Web Part | SharePoint Maven
How to use Microsoft Planner
How to use Microsoft Planner

Smartsheet, by contrast, uses a more traditional grid-based interface that might require some learning time for those new to project management tools. However, it offers a high degree of customization, and its familiar spreadsheet format often appeals to teams that have outgrown Excel for task management.

Visual Timeline

Microsoft Planner includes a built-in, visual timeline feature that displays tasks across a timescale. This is a significant advantage for teams that need to see their plans in chronological order to identify potential gaps or overlaps.

Microsoft Project vs Smartsheet: Best Choice for 2026
Microsoft Project vs Smartsheet: Best Choice for 2026
Microsoft Planner Best Practices | SharePoint Maven
Microsoft Planner Best Practices | SharePoint Maven
Microsoft Planner Templates
Microsoft Planner Templates

While Smartsheet does offer Gantt charts for visual project scheduling, it doesn't have a built-in timeline feature like Planner. However, Smartsheet's strength lies in its flexibility and advanced features, such as dashboards and reports, that can be used to create custom project views.

Integration

Being part of the Microsoft 365 suite, Planner integrates seamlessly with other Microsoft apps like Teams, Outlook, and OneNote. This makes it an excellent choice for Microsoft-centric organizations.

AD

Smartsheet hasn't quite achieved the same level of integration with other popular suites. However, it offers connections with essential third-party apps like Salesforce, Slack, and Jira. It also provides APIs for custom integrations.

Lists or Planner? | SharePoint Maven
Lists or Planner? | SharePoint Maven
an image of a dashboard showing the different tasks that people can use to manage their work
an image of a dashboard showing the different tasks that people can use to manage their work
How to Use Microsoft Planner to Manage Your Project (2024)
How to Use Microsoft Planner to Manage Your Project (2024)
Microsoft Planner Updates
Microsoft Planner Updates
Daily & Weekly Planner - Clear Button - Google Sheets Template - Daily Schedule - Checklist
Daily & Weekly Planner - Clear Button - Google Sheets Template - Daily Schedule - Checklist
Microsoft to add Project features to its new unified Planner work management app
Microsoft to add Project features to its new unified Planner work management app

Task Management Features

Both tools offer comprehensive task management features, but there are key differences in how they approach task organization and tracking.

Microsoft Planner groups tasks into 'buckets' for better organization. Users can add due dates, labels, and use different views (like Board, Chart, or Timeline) to manage tasks more effectively. Planner's unique ' progress' feature estimates task completion based on spent time, providing a real-time snapshot of project progress.

AD

Task Dependencies

Smartsheet excels in managing complex task dependencies. It allows users to link tasks to show which ones should be completed before another begins. This is particularly useful for large, intricate projects.

Planner doesn't offer native task dependency features. While it's possible to track dependencies manually using labels or board views, this requires more manual effort.

Task Hierarchy

Smartsheet's task hierarchy provides an exceptional level of detail, allowing users to create tasks, sub-tasks, and sub-subtasks. This is invaluable for large, complex projects with many subtasks.

AD

Planner's task hierarchy is less developed, with only a basic task/subtask structure. However, this works well for simpler projects and teams just starting with project management tools.

Collaboration and Communication

Both tools foster collaboration, but they have different approaches to communication and teamwork.

Microsoft Planner's visually engaging interface promotes collaboration with its drag-and-drop task cards and easy-to-read, color-coded labels. Plus, its seamless integration with Microsoft Teams encourages team discussions around tasks.

Smartsheet enables collaboration through its Comment feature, which lets team members comment on specific cells or entire rows. It also offers workflow automation, allowing teams to automate actions based on task changes, and real-time editing, which allows multiple team members to work on the same project simultaneously.

Group Conversations

Planner doesn't provide a dedicated space for group conversations. It relies on integrations with other Microsoft apps, like Teams, for team discussions.

Smartsheet offers in-app Group Conversations, allowing teams to collaborate right within the project. This can lead to more streamlined communication, though it might not be as robust as a dedicated chat app like Microsoft Teams.

Both Microsoft Planner and Smartsheet have their strengths and cater to different user needs. Microsoft Planner is ideal for teams new to project management or those looking for a more visual, intuitive task management experience. Smartsheet, on the other hand, is a powerhouse for more experienced project managers, offering sophisticated features for complex project management. The best choice between the two depends on your team's specific requirements and how they work best.

AD