pragmatic theory of linguistics

Pragmatic Theory of Linguistics

By Anthony Walker
AD

The Pragmatic Theory of Linguistics, proposed by philosopher Willard Van Orman Quine, is a groundbreaking approach that emphasizes the role of communication and context in language comprehension. It's a departure from traditional linguistic theories that focus primarily on syntax and semantics. By understanding this theory, we gain a more holistic perspective on how language works and its impact on our society.

The Pragmatic Theory of Linguistics introduces notions such as speaker intention, context, and audience interpretation, highlighting the dynamic nature of language. It argues that meanings of words and sentences aren't inherent but rather emerge from their usage in a specific situation. Let's dive deeper into its key aspects.

Speaker's Intention

At the core of the Pragmatic Theory lies the concept of intentionality. According to Quine, the speaker's intention plays a pivotal role in shaping the meaning of an utterance. A speaker's meaning isn't simply the literal interpretation of their words but encompasses their aim in communicating.

AD
Language & Linguistics Pragmatics: Speech Acts
Language & Linguistics Pragmatics: Speech Acts
Semantics vs Pragmatics in Linguistics: Meaning and Differences
Semantics vs Pragmatics in Linguistics: Meaning and Differences
Second Language Pragmatics : From Theory to Research - 9781138911772
Second Language Pragmatics : From Theory to Research - 9781138911772

A famous example illustrating this is 'Greeting Paradox'. A speaker might say "Hello" with different intentions - to greet, to indicate awareness of someone, or to ask a question. The meaning changes based on the speaker's intention and the context.

Illocutionary Force

Speech acts scholar John Austin expanded on Quine's ideas, introducing 'illocutionary force'. This refers to what the speaker aims to achieve by making an utterance. For instance, asking a question, issuing an order, or making a statement. The illocutionary force can change the meaning of the same sentence. Saying "Close the door" can be either a request or a command, depending on the context and intention.

a coffee cup with the words pragmatic language in it
a coffee cup with the words pragmatic language in it
Pragmatics (MEG 04 Unit 14) 📚 Pragmatics = meaning in context Key concepts: • Speech Acts • Deixis
Pragmatics (MEG 04 Unit 14) 📚 Pragmatics = meaning in context Key concepts: • Speech Acts • Deixis
a poster with different types of writing and numbers on it, including thesauruss
a poster with different types of writing and numbers on it, including thesauruss

For example, in a doctored script, if an actor's line "I do" is said with the illocutionary force of making a promise, it's a legal marriage. If said with the illocutionary force of accepting the outcome of a game, it's a trivial comment.

Performativity

Another key element of Pragmatic Theory is 'performativity', where saying something makes it so. In performative utterances, the saying is part of the doing. For instance, saying "I apologize" is an action of apologizing, and saying "I appoint you the CEO" appoints the person as CEO. These can't be reduced to mere statements of fact.

AD

J.L. Austin's example of "I do" in a wedding ceremony is a classic instance of performativity. By saying "I do", the couple isn't describing a state but declaring a new state - the state of being married.

the four types of phonology are shown in different colors and sizes, including red, yellow, blue, green, and orange
the four types of phonology are shown in different colors and sizes, including red, yellow, blue, green, and orange
Pragmatics in Linguistics | Definition | Fields
Pragmatics in Linguistics | Definition | Fields
Pragmetics 28
Pragmetics 28
Pragmatics (Oxford Textbooks in Linguistics)
Pragmatics (Oxford Textbooks in Linguistics)
a diagram that shows the structure of language
a diagram that shows the structure of language
Pragmemes and Theories of Language Use
Pragmemes and Theories of Language Use

The Role of Context

Context is equally crucial in shaping meaning. In Pragmatic Theory, the same sentence can have different meanings in different contexts. The 'You might want to close the door' example illustrates this. Said on a freezing night, it's a suggestion for warmth. Said to a child, it could be a command for privacy. The intended meaning is heavily influenced by the situation.

Eugene Chao's 'dogs' vs ' Dogs' example further underscores this. 'Dogs' in lowercase refers to the animals, while 'Dogs' in uppercase could refer to a rock band or British slang for policemen. The meaning isn't inherent in the words but arises based on the context in which they're used.

AD

Deixis

Deixis is another aspect of context-dependent meaning. Dependent on context, deictic expressions like 'I', 'you', 'here', 'there', 'now', and 'then' can shift their referents based on the speaker's location or time. For instance, 'Here' doesn't refer to a fixed location but to where the speaker is.

Difference Between Semantics and Pragmatics - Pediaa.Com
Difference Between Semantics and Pragmatics - Pediaa.Com

Similarly, 'Now' doesn't denote a specific point in time but refers to the time when the speaker is talking. So, a poem saying "Now I see it" doesn't convey a permanent insight but a momentary one based on the speaker's current experience.

Conversational Implicitures

Conversational Implicitures, as proposed by H. Paul Grice, are elements that aren't explicitly stated in the conversation but are understood based on the context. These implicitures fill in the gaps in a conversation, making communication efficient. For example, if A asks B "Where's the library?" and B replies "It's across the park", A understands B means 'You can walk across the park to reach the library', even though B didn't explicitly state it.

AD

These implicitures are often based on assumptions about the world, common knowledge, or the purposes of the conversation. They're central to Pragmatic Theory as they highlight the intertwined nature of language and context.

In closing, the Pragmatic Theory of Linguistics revolutionized our understanding of language by emphasizing communication, context, and intention. By understanding Pragmatic Theory, we gain valuable insights into the dynamic, flexible nature of language, redefining how we interact, comprehend, and use it in our daily lives. Thus, it's not just a linguistic theory but a vital tool for effective communication. Embrace this holistic perspective for a rich, meaningful linguistic experience.

AD