Protractor Review: Automating End-to-End Web Tests
Protractor, an end-to-end (E2E) test framework for Angular and AngularJS applications, has been a go-to tool for quality assurance (QA) engineer due to its robust functionality and simplicity. But how does it fare in the face of modern testing requirements? Let's delve into a comprehensive review of Protractor, explore its strengths, weaknesses, and alternatives.
Protractor's foundation lies in its semantics-based locators and Angular-specific features, making it an excellent fit for testing Angular-based web applications. However, it's essential to understand how it fares in the broader landscape of testing tools.
Protractor's Strengths
Angular-specific Commands: Protractor includes commands designed specifically for Angular, making it easier to automate tests compared to using other Selenium-based tools.
Synced with Angular: Protractor runs each test in its own browser instance. This synchronization ensures that test actions occur after the page is fully loaded, allowing accurate testing of Angular-specific features.
User-friendly Locators
Protractor uses Angular's unique model to find elements, making locators user-friendly and less prone to errors compared to traditional xPath or CSS Selectors.
Example: protractor finds elements using 'by.model' and 'by.binding', which are directly tied to the Angular model and binding syntax, making them more intuitive.
Seleniumuppertime
Protractor is built on top of WebDriverJS, which in turn is built on top of Selenium, giving it the robustness and reliability of a Selenium-based tool.
This Selenium uptime translates to Protractor as widely supported browsers (Chrome, Firefox, Safari), a large community, and extensive documentation.
Protractor's Weaknesses
The following aspects of Protractor might pose challenges for your QA team, depending on your specific needs.
Speed: Protractor's synchronization process, while ensuring accurate results, can be slow. This slowness can lead to significantly longer test suites compared to other tools like Jest or Mocha.
Not Ideal for Non-Angular Apps
As Protractor is built specifically for Angular and AngularJS, it's not the best fit for non-Angular applications. Using it for non-Angular applications can lead to more complex and less efficient tests.
While it's possible to use Protractor for non-Angular apps with hybrid locators, it's usually recommended to use a more suitable tool for such cases.
Large Test Suites Can be Challenging
Protractor shines with small to medium-sized test suites but can struggle with very large ones. This is due to its in-built synchronization and the fact that each test runs in its own instance.
To mitigate this, you may need to use advanced configurations or consider switching to a tool better suited for large test suites.
Alternatives to Protractor
While Protractor is an excellent choice for many Angular projects, let's explore a couple of tools that could serve as viable alternatives.
Cypress.io: Cypress is a modern end-to-end testing framework that combines the best of both worlds. It provides a rich API for specifying complex interactions, supports Geolocation API, Network throttling, forcing sync calls, and more. Plus, it's built on top of Mocha, ensuring fast speed and extensive capabilities.
Jest with Puppeteer
Jest is a powerful testing framework developed by Facebook, offering speed, extensive API, and an intuitive interface. When coupled with Puppeteer (a Node library using Chrome's DevTools Protocol), it forms a formidable E2E solution for both Angular and non-Angular applications.
This combination, while not an Angular-specific solution, offers a flexible and powerful alternative, especially for large test suites or non-Angular applications.
In conclusion, Protractor is an excellent tool for testing Angular applications, providing a robust, Angular-specific, and user-friendly testing experience. However, its speed limitations and suboptimal performance with non-Angular apps make it essential to consider other tools for specific requirements. The key is to understand your project's unique needs and find the tool best suited for your team's workflow.