scotch order specification nyt

Scotch Whisky: Order Specs from New York Times

By David Walker
AD

The New York Times (NYT) is renowned for its meticulous approach to journalism, which is reflected in its "Scotch order specification." This guiding document outlines a strict protocol for the referencing and citation of external sources in NYT articles. It ensures consistency and credibility in their reporting, aligning with their commitment to truth and accuracy. Let's delve into the key aspects of this specification.

As a journalist working for the NYT, understanding the Scotch order is not just important, but crucial for maintaining the publication's high standards. It is the cornerstone of their verification process, ensuring that every claim is backed by reliable evidence.

Understanding the Scotch Order

The Scotch order is a set of rules that spells out how NYT journalists should attribute information and handle sourcing. The name originates from the Times' former executive editor, Abe Rosenthal, who would sign off his edited copy with the phrase 'Scotch Tape It Now,' indicating the need for further confirmation.

AD
a poster with the words scotch tasting chart and an image of a wine glass on it
a poster with the words scotch tasting chart and an image of a wine glass on it
the different types of whiskys are shown in this chart, which shows their names
the different types of whiskys are shown in this chart, which shows their names
a poster with different types of food and beverages on it, including bourbon and scotch
a poster with different types of food and beverages on it, including bourbon and scotch

The order is named after Claiborne 'Scotch' Centner, a meteorologist who was famously meticulous in his note-taking and record-keeping – traits valued by Rosenthal in journalists.

Scotch's 12 Guidelines

The Scotch order specifics are often embodied in twelve guidelines attributed to Mr. Centner. These include:

an advertisement for a single mal scotch whisky, with information about the product and description
an advertisement for a single mal scotch whisky, with information about the product and description
an info sheet describing how to use the scotch label for whiskeys and other beverages
an info sheet describing how to use the scotch label for whiskeys and other beverages
four glasses filled with different types of whiskey
four glasses filled with different types of whiskey
  1. Always identify your sources by their real names, if possible.
  2. If you must use an unnamed source, be ready to explain why.
  3. Make sure your sources are credible and reliable.
  4. Never quote a source unless you have proof – a recording, a note, or a second source.
  5. If you use a quote, attribute it.
  6. Always verify facts with a second source.
  7. Be transparent about how you obtained your information...
  8. ...and about any limitations in your reporting.
  9. Show the context. Provide enough information for readers to understand the source...
  10. ...and to evaluate its plausibility.
  11. Double-check all facts.
  12. When in doubt, leave it out.

These guidelines are("not designed to paralyze reporters into inaction," according to Jill Abramson, former executive editor of the NYT, but rather to "encourage them to be bold and imaginative in finding new ways to cover news.")

The Scotch Order in Practice

The NYT's newsroom verifies information through a robust system of fact-checking, involving multiple reporters, desks, and editors. Every piece of information is cross-referenced and confirmed through at least two independent sources before publication.

AD

This process ensures that the NYT adheres to its commitment to fairness, accuracy, and transparency, making it an industry leader in maintaining the highest standards of journalistic integrity.

four different types of whiskey are shown in this diagram
four different types of whiskey are shown in this diagram
WHISKEY
WHISKEY
the 5 steps to scotch whisky poster with instructions on how to use it and what to do
the 5 steps to scotch whisky poster with instructions on how to use it and what to do
Bourbon, Scotch
Bourbon, Scotch
We respect your privacy
We respect your privacy
Pour a dram, let it breathe, and join the gathering of taste. 🥃✨
Pour a dram, let it breathe, and join the gathering of taste. 🥃✨

The Scotch Order and the CNN Effect

The rigorous sourcing standards of the Scotch order have been influential beyond the NYT. The CNN Effect, referring to the impact of CNN's 24/7 news cycle on journalism, also pushed for more timely reporting and quicker news turnaround. However, the NYT's emphasis on slow, meticulous fact-checking has remained unyielding, even as media landscapes shift.

NYT journalists are thus trained to balance speed with accuracy, using the Scotch order as their compass. This balance, though seemingly contradictory, has not only sustained the NYT's journalistic integrity but also set the bar for integrity in journalism itself.

AD

The Scotch order is more than just a specification; it is the NYT's enduring commitment to truth and accountability in journalism. It serves as a testament to the power of diligence and accuracy in maintaining public trust. As such, it remains a cornerstone of the NYT's mission and a guiding principle for journalists worldwide.

an info sheet describing the different types of whiskys and how they are used to make them
an info sheet describing the different types of whiskys and how they are used to make them
AD