secret subway menu

Unveiling NYC's Best Kept Secret: The Subway Menu You're Not Seeing

By Joseph Thomas
AD

Mysterious menus tucked away in our everyday commute? You bet! Dive into the fascinating world of the 'secret subway menus,' uncharted territories known only to the initiated and the intrepid. So, are you ready to hop on the adventure and explore the tumultuous yet offbeat culinary journey of our urban underground systems?

Prepare to be astounded! These hidden edible treasures are not just about subs and sandwiches. They're urban legends that weave through the maze of subway lines, echoing the culture, history, and quirky habits of the cities they serve. Let's embark on an expedition, from the bustling streets of New York to the romantic alleyways of Paris, to unveil the secret subway menus that'll make your taste buds dance.

The Big Apple's Backroom Bites

Kickstarting our gastronomic journey is the city that never sleeps – New York. The subway here is not just a means of transport; it's a living, breathing entity with stories etched onto its walls. Scattered amongst its 472 stations lies a mouth-watering secret: backroom eateries serving up local delicacies.

AD
15 Subway Secret Menu Items to Try
15 Subway Secret Menu Items to Try
two pictures one has a sandwich and the other has a sign that says, if you ask subway will make it
two pictures one has a sandwich and the other has a sign that says, if you ask subway will make it
Rather-Be-Shopping Blog | Shopping Hacks, Return Policies and Coupons
Rather-Be-Shopping Blog | Shopping Hacks, Return Policies and Coupons

Historic places like the McSorley's Old Ale House in East Houston Street have been doling out their iconic dark beer and ginger ale since 1854. You might miss it if you're not looking for the discreet sign bearing its name. Think you can find it? Remember, secrets are meant to be sought out, not laid bare.

Thin crusts & deep dips

Looking for a slice? Lombardi's, NYC's first pizzeria, has been serving coal-oven baked pies since 1905. Their secret? A crispy thin crust and that legendary tomato sauce recipe. But shh, don't tell anyone you heard it from us. We'd hate to see their secret getting more popular than the city's subway art.

the subway menu is shown with different subs and sandwiches in each section on it
the subway menu is shown with different subs and sandwiches in each section on it
the subway menu features subs, sandwiches and salads for lunch or dinner time
the subway menu features subs, sandwiches and salads for lunch or dinner time
Hungry Girl
Hungry Girl

We're not done with our pizza quest yet! For another slice of history, check out Grimaldi's beneath the Brooklyn Bridge. The smell of their coal-fired brick-oven pizzas will lure you in. But let's keep it our little secret, okay? Let's not overwhelm them with our thousands of shared pins and likes.

Burgers so big, they need a map

New York isn't just about the pizzas and beers. Let's talk about burgers. Juicy Lucy's on the Upper East Side boasts the 'Big-Ass Burger' – a double patty, cheese-filled delight. We can already taste the celebration of flavors, from the slightly sweet, caramelized onions to the smoky bacon. But hey, not everyone can handle the heat, so maybe keep this one to yourself.

AD

Now, how about a burger so big it needs its own street map? Welcome to the 'Breakfast of Humpty Dumpty' at S'murgTools. It's not every day you see a burger the size of your head, let alone a whole new world of delight with Sunny Side Up, turkey bacon, and maple syrup. But hush, this one's gasoline on our secret menu fire.

Here Is How To Order The Chipotle Breakfast Chicken Sub Off The Subway Secret Menu
Here Is How To Order The Chipotle Breakfast Chicken Sub Off The Subway Secret Menu
Antigua and Barbuda Caribbean Vacation travel and tourism holiday information guide
Antigua and Barbuda Caribbean Vacation travel and tourism holiday information guide
a large sub sandwich with many different toppings on it's wrapper, in front of a multi - colored background
a large sub sandwich with many different toppings on it's wrapper, in front of a multi - colored background
a poster with different types of food on it's sides and the words build a subway sandwich
a poster with different types of food on it's sides and the words build a subway sandwich
the history of subway through the years
the history of subway through the years
the subway menu is posted on the glass
the subway menu is posted on the glass

London's Undercover Nosh

Crossing the Atlantic, we find ourselves in London, home to the oldest subway network in the world. Here, secrets lurk behind every corner, and the best dishes aren't always on the surface. Our mission? To uncover the hidden foodie treasures lurking in the labyrinth of the London Underground.

Prepare your taste buds for an adrenaline rush. From sushi hidden behind a Goodge Street sign to secret-society-inspired cocktail bars like the.prop.shop, London's hardly letting you off the hook with just a Boris Bike and a cup of tea.

AD

Sushi straight from the source

We're kicking off with a raw deal for sushi lovers. Hidden behind the opaque windows of Goodge Street station lies a tiny Japanese kitchen producing mouthwatering sashimi and nigiri. Shhh, it's a secret – we don't want the hordes of fish-cravers to overrun this speck of Japanese excellence.

SUBWAY SECRET MENU | Secret Menus Guru
SUBWAY SECRET MENU | Secret Menus Guru

Now, for those craving a tummy-tickling fusion of flavors, seek out the modest cart of Cult. From their smoky BBQ pulled pork buns to the pork belly vindaloo, Cult delivers the kind of scran that makes your arteries clog with joy.

Prohibition-style tipples

London Underground might not be pulsating with bootleggers like New York, but that doesn't mean the city's bar scene stops at the station platforms. From the echoes of Prohibition to the booming sound of youth culture, London's speakeasy offerings are as ripe as they are varied.

AD

We're talking about the carnivalesque joy of the Nightjar, hidden away behind a red-painted door in the heart of Shoreditch. Or how about a splash of Copper Hind, shaken up in the inner sanctum of the century-old White Horse pub in Parson's Green?

The secret subway menu is not just about the food; it's about the journey. It's about the nooks and crannies, the stories waiting to be discovered, and the adventures that weave into the very fabric of each bustling city. So the next time you're underground, step out of your comfort zone, and go find that perfect bite. Who knows – you might just stumble upon the next big secret. And when you do, don't forget to drag your friends along. After all, sharing is caring. Bon appétit.

AD