Star Trek: Discovery Season 1 Rating - Critics and Fans Weigh In
Fans of the legendary "Star Trek" franchise were eagerly awaiting the debut of "Discovery" in 2017, and the series' first season certainly lived up to the hype, capturing a unique audience that has continued to grow. But how well did "Discovery" Season 1 truly fare? Let's delve into the critical reception and ratings that shaped the season's success.
Before we dive in, let's briefly set the stage. "Discovery" Season 1, released on CBS All Access (now Paramount+), is set roughly a decade before the original series, in the prime timeline. It follows lieutenant commander Sarah “Saru” Finn and the crew of the USS Discovery NCC-1031 as they explore new worlds and encounter new civilizations in the name of peace and godspeed.
Critical Reception and Initial Ratings
The first season of "Discovery" received widespread critical acclaim, with many praising the show's fresh take on the "Star Trek" formula while still honoring the franchise's roots. However, the road to widespread acceptance was not entirely smooth.
Within the first few weeks of its release, "Discovery" Season 1 received a mixed bag of reviews. Some critics lauded the show's visuals, performances, and exploration of new themes, while others found the pacing slow and the narrative disjointed. Nevertheless, as the season progressed, reviews became overwhelmingly positive, with many critics hailing it as one of the strongest entries in the "Star Trek" canon.
Positive Aspects: Visuals, Themes, and Performances
One of the standout features of "Discovery" Season 1 was its striking visual effects and production design. Both critics and audiences alike marveled at the show's stunning depictions of alien worlds, meticulously designed starships, and intricate costume design. The season's visuals truly encapsulated the wonder and excitement of exploration at the heart of "Star Trek."
The season also tackled themes and issues that resonated with viewers, such as the consequences of war, the struggle for belonging, and the complexities of command. By weaving contemporary themes into its science fiction narrative, "Discovery" Season 1 struck a chord with audiences and sparked thought-provoking discussions.
Challenges and Criticism: Pacing and Tone
Despite its many strengths, "Discovery" Season 1 faced criticism for its uneven pacing, particularly during the first few episodes. Some viewers found the slow burn frustrating, while others appreciated the intricate setup of the season's overarching narrative. This discord in pacing is a common issue in serialized television, but it did not ultimately deter fans from engaging with the season.
A handful of critics also took issue with the season's darker tone, arguing that it strayed too far from the optimistic spirit of the classic "Star Trek" series. However, many viewers welcomed the shift in tone, as it allowed "Discovery" to delve into more nuanced and tonal depths than previous "Star Trek" series had explored.
Ratings and Viewership
Despite the initial mixed reviews, "Discovery" Season 1 demonstrated strong viewership numbers and steadily climbed in popularity throughout its run. According to CBS, the debut season garnered over 15 million viewers across its initial broadcast on both the CBS network and CBS All Access.
The show also performed well in live-plus-three (L3) viewership, which combines same-day viewership with three days of time-shifted viewing. This metric is particularly relevant for "Discovery," as it helps paint a more accurate picture of the show's audience, given the popularity of streaming platforms and delays in viewership due to their on-demand nature.
Improving Ratings Throughout the Season
As mentioned earlier, initial reviews of "Discovery" Season 1 were mixed, but as the season progressed, critical reception became increasingly positive. This shift was reflected in the show's growing viewership numbers. By the time the season finale aired, "Discovery" had established itself as a strong performer in the CBS All Access lineup and a compelling addition to the "Star Trek" franchise.
Moreover, "Discovery" Season 1 consistently maintained its place in the top 10 original streaming series of 2017, solidifying its status as a must-watch title for subscribers. The season's ratings also played a significant role in CBS's decision to renew "Discovery" for subsequent seasons, ultimately leading to the show's ongoing success.
Looking ahead, "Star Trek: Discovery" Season 1 has left an indelible mark on the "Star Trek" universe, paving the way for further exploration and innovative storytelling. As the franchise continues to grow with new series and films, the success of "Discovery"'s maiden voyage serves as a testament to the enduring appeal of the "Star Trek" story and its ability to captivate new generations of fans. Be sure to keep an eye out for new updates and releases, as the final frontier continues to expand in exciting and unexpected ways.