what did the pragmatic sanction of bourges establish

What Did the Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges Establish

By Daniel Lee
AD

The Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges, issued in 1438, was a pivotal moment in European history, marking a significant shift in institutional Reformation that would later influence the broader course of Christianity. Thiscame at a crucial juncture in the Catholic Church's history, setting precedence for the reconsideration of practices and beliefs that would lead to the Protestant Reformation a century later. But what exactly did this sanction establish?

The Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges was a document crafted to reassert French royal authority over the French Church in response to the increasing influence of the Avignon papacy, known as the 'Babylonian Captivity'. The sanction's establishment set a raft of radical changes in motion, reshaping the French Catholic Church's governance, jurisdiction, and practices. Understanding its implications necessitates delving into the sanction's core aspects.

The Reassertion of Royal Authority

The sanctions' primary achievement was the reassertion of French royal authority over the French Church. Prior to its enactment, the Avignon papacy had exercised substantial influence over French ecclesiastical affairs, often bypassing French monarchs. The sanction officially returned control to the French crown.

AD
an old drawing of people standing in front of a man sitting on the ground with his foot
an old drawing of people standing in front of a man sitting on the ground with his foot
a painting of a man signing a document in front of a group of men and women
a painting of a man signing a document in front of a group of men and women
a large room filled with lots of people sitting at desks in front of them
a large room filled with lots of people sitting at desks in front of them

Through the sanction, King Charles VII declared that no bull of the Pope was to be executed in his kingdom without his approval. This effectively created a system of 'concordat' where the Pope retained ultimate spiritual authority but the king controlled ecclesiastical governance within his kingdom.

Regalian Right over Benefices

The Pragmatic Sanction also confirmed the 'regalian right' of French monarchs to benefices - ecclesiastical offices and incomes - during vacancies. This gave the king the right to appoint bishops, abbots, and other Church officials during their deaths or removals, effectively exercised during the 'royal vacancies'.

an image of a large crowd in a building that is filled with men and women
an image of a large crowd in a building that is filled with men and women
1948 - Nederland, België, Luxemburg, Frankrijk en het Verenigd Koninkrijk tekenen op 17 maart 1948 h
1948 - Nederland, België, Luxemburg, Frankrijk en het Verenigd Koninkrijk tekenen op 17 maart 1948 h
Hugonet, the chancellor of Duchess Maria of Burgundy, was executed in 1477
Hugonet, the chancellor of Duchess Maria of Burgundy, was executed in 1477

Prior to this, such positions were often reserved for French nobles. But by assuming this right, Charles VII could appoint clerics who were more loyal to his crown, further consolidating royal power.

Regulation of Taxation

Another significant aspect of the pragmatic sanction was its regulation of taxation within the Church. It allowed the king to tax Church properties and incomes, particularly during times of war or emergency. This gave Charles VII the means to finance his campaigns against the Hundred Years' War.

AD

Previously, such taxation was heavily opposed by the clergy on grounds of tax immunity. But the sanction officially recognized taxation powers, giving the king greater financial control over ecclesiastical affairs.

four men sitting at a table in front of a big screen with the words brics on it
four men sitting at a table in front of a big screen with the words brics on it
a group of men standing next to each other in front of flags
a group of men standing next to each other in front of flags
1566: When a Petition Becomes a Movement (Apr 5)
1566: When a Petition Becomes a Movement (Apr 5)
Napoleon & Consulate. Installation du Conseil d'État au palais du Petit-Luxembourg, 25 décembre 1799
Napoleon & Consulate. Installation du Conseil d'État au palais du Petit-Luxembourg, 25 décembre 1799
several people sitting around a table with flags on it
several people sitting around a table with flags on it
US Senate advances revised version of Russia sanctions bill
US Senate advances revised version of Russia sanctions bill

The Influence on the Later Church Reformation

The Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges, although rooted in French royal interests, had profound long-term implications on Christianity generally. It slowed the spread of Hondlet Great Schism and set a precedent for sovereign control over religious affairs.

Centuries later, Martin Luther would draw inspiration from these principles, particularly the idea of 'Ecclesia reformata, reformans' - a '"reformed" church must "re-form". This would later form a cornerstone of the Protestant Reformation, which would challenge the Catholic Church's authority and lead to significant changes across Europe.

AD

The Pragmatic Sanction of Bourges, more than a century before the Protestant Reformation, effectively became a vanguard of the future transformation of Christianity. Understanding its establishment thus offers valuable insights into the deeper currents of religious change and reform in Europe.

Gouverner sans majorité : les conseils d’amis belges pour former une coalition
Gouverner sans majorité : les conseils d’amis belges pour former une coalition
AD