"What Does Piggy Really Represent?"
The phrase "Piggy" in George Orwell's dystopian novel "Animal Farm" is a personification of the brutal and oppressive power dynamics that the leaders of the revolution, Snowball and Napoleon, embody. The animal characters in the story adopt names from human history to personify different emotions, ideologies, and power structures.
Orwell chose the name "Napoleon" to represent Stalin, the leader of the Soviet Union who had immense power and a perceived brutal nature, whereas "Snowball" is based on Leon Trotsky, a Russian revolutionary who formed a democratic opposition to Stalin's growing authoritarianism.
Napoleon as Stalin
Napoleon, a boar, represents Stalin's brutal and totalitarian rule. Orwell compares Napoleon's tactics to Stalin's as both use manipulation, fear, and violence to maintain power.
Napoleon's encroachment on the other animals' rights, such as his declaration that the windmill's construction was his idea to which he holds exclusive rights, mirrors Stalin's nationalization of industries. Napoleon's appearance above the other animals in likeness to Stalin's portrait on all public buildings echoes the cult of personality that Stalin established in the Soviet Union.
Use of Fear and Violence
Napoleon instills fear into the other animals by exploiting their innate fears, such as using the dogs (his secret police) to threaten and coerce others. This reflects Stalin's use of the political police to maintain his grip on power, as seen in his Great Purge of the 1930s.
Napoleon's use of the dogs as a violent force against the animals is another nod to Stalin's regime. This brutal tactic is embodied by phrases like "We will shoot on sight" and "We must crush this rebellion."
Manipulation and Clarity
Napoleon's manipulation of facts and language is another way Orwell highlights Stalin's tactics. By rewriting history and controlling information, Napoleon keeps the other animals ignorant and unable to challenge him. This is a clear reference to Stalin's control of the media, censorship, and his systematic rewriting of history.
Napoleon's introduction of twin codes, the "Four Legs Good, Two Legs Bad" and "Napoleon is Always Right," demonstrates Stalin's manipulation of language and thought. These codes limit the animals' notions and facilitate the perpetuation of Napoleon's rule.
Snowball as Trotsky
Contrasting with Napoleon, Snowball represents Leon Trotsky, a revolutionary and a political opponent to Stalin. The character of Snowball is portrayed as having democratic ideals and an emphasis on logical and critical thought.
Snowball's advocacy of education, his use of incentives, and his emphasis on camaraderie show a leaning towards Trotsky's ideology. However, Snowball does not truly stand as a symbol of democracy, as his ruthless tactics at times mirror Napoleon's.
Democracy and Education
Snowball encourages learning among the animals and advocates for a more democratic society. Similar to Trotsky, Snowball values education and emphasizes the importance of the revolutionaries' ideology.
Snowball's encouragement of chickens to become confessors and spies among the other animals is at odds with the character's early advocacy for democracy and shows the thin line between these ideologies and their corrupting power.
Incentives
Snowball uses a system of rewards, such as extra rations and praise, to motivate and control the animals more subtly than Napoleon. This manipulation shows that Snowball, despite advocating for a decentralized, democratic society, is capable of manipulating beliefs for his own advantage.
Snowball's use of the Seven Commandments emphasizes both his willingness to reward those who continue to support his ideas and his power to manipulate language and thought among the other animals. The commandments ultimately serve to maintain Snowball's rule.
In the end, "Piggy" represents the worst qualities of both Stalin and Trotsky. Napoleon's resort to excessive violence and fearmongering, coupled with Snowball's use of manipulation and the manipulation of language, create a society that ultimately oppresses the animals. In "Animal Farm," Orwell shows a clear warning of the perils of absolute power, regardless of the ideals it professes.