what happens to unvested rsus during an acquisition

What Happens to Unvested RSUs in an Acquisition

By Thomas Garcia
AD

When a tech company or startup goes through an acquisition, there's often much buzz around what happens to the employees, their equity, and especially, their Restricted Stock Units (RSUs). If you're a stakeholder wondering about the fate of your unvested RSUs in an acquisition, you're not alone. In this comprehensive guide, we'll delve into the key aspects of what transpires when unvested RSUs are involved in a startup acquisition.

Before we dive in, it's crucial to understand that the specific treatment of unvested RSUs during an acquisition depends significantly on the terms negotiated between the acquirer and the target company. However, there are some common scenarios and best practices that can guide your understanding.

Treatment of Unvested RSUs During a Merger or Acquisition

The typical fate of unvested RSUs in a merger or acquisition (M&A) can be categorized into three main outcomes: cash settlement, RSU acceleration, or vesting schedule continuation. Each scenario comes with its advantages and disadvantages for both employees and the acquiring company.

AD
When to Sell RSUs for Tech Employees
When to Sell RSUs for Tech Employees
How to Make Customers Return: Turning One-Time Buyers into Long-Term Value
How to Make Customers Return: Turning One-Time Buyers into Long-Term Value
HOW RSI WORKS
HOW RSI WORKS

Cash Settlement of Unvested RSUs

One of the most straightforward outcomes is for the acquirer to compensate employees for their unvested RSUs with a cash payment. The company calculates the value of the unvested RSUs based on the closing stock price on the acquisition date, less any taxes due upon exercise. This method is advantageous for the acquirer as it simplifies their equity compensation post-acquisition.

However, cash settlement can lead to employee dissatisfaction, as they may prefer to retain their equity and upside potential. Moreover, the proceeds are subject to immediate taxation, which can result in a higher tax burden for the employees. From a compensation perspective, cash settlement may also peg employee value to a single point in time, potentially undervaluing their contributions in a growing company.

two men in business suits are shaking hands with each other at a desk that has puzzle pieces on it
two men in business suits are shaking hands with each other at a desk that has puzzle pieces on it
Effects of Recession
Effects of Recession
an image of a futuristic city with lots of things on it
an image of a futuristic city with lots of things on it

Acceleration of RSU Vesting Schedule

Another common approach is for the acquirer to accelerate the vesting schedule of the unvested RSUs. This means that the unvested RSUs are immediately vested, allowing employees to exercise their options (if applicable) or retain their equity as shares in the acquiring company. Acceleration is often used to motivate employees and maintain morale post-acquisition, as it enables them to participate in the growth potential of the new company.

However, accelerating RSU vesting schedules can be costly for the acquiring company, as it immediately dilutes the equity of existing shareholders. Moreover, employees may still face tax implications upon exercise, depending on the acquisition's structure and the applicable tax laws. To mitigate these issues, some acquirers may offer tax planning strategies or other forms of compensation to offset the tax burden.

AD

The Role of Employment Contracts and Agreements

Employment contracts and agreement terms play a significant role in determining how unvested RSUs are treated during an acquisition. In most cases, the target company's equity incentive plans and employment agreements outline the vesting schedules, acceleration rights, and what happens to unvested RSUs upon a change of control or acquisition.

Stock Options vs RSUs - what's the difference?
Stock Options vs RSUs - what's the difference?
Effects of Recession
Effects of Recession

Change of Control Provisions

Change of control provisions in employment agreements and equity incentive plans specify what happens to RSUs (both vested and unvested) if the company undergoes a change of control, such as an acquisition. These provisions may dictate whether RSUs are accelerated, cashed out, or continue to vest under the original schedule. Understanding these provisions before an acquisition can help employees and the target company better navigate the M&A process.

Activation of change of control provisions depends on how the acquisition is structured and the specific definition of "change of control" in the agreements. In some cases, a simple majority vote by the board of directors might suffice, while other definitions may require a more significant change, such as a change in control group, a sale of substantially all assets, or a dissolution of the company.

AD

As a side note, acquiring companies should be mindful of change of control provisions in target company agreements, as they may entitle key employees to significant payouts or acceleration upon completion of the acquisition. Negotiating adjustments to these provisions or other forms of compensation can help the acquirer retain talented employees and mitigate the costs associated with accelerated vesting or cash settlement.

Acquisition Agreement Terms

In addition to employment agreements, acquisition agreements between the buyer and seller often dictate how unvested RSUs are treated. These terms may align with the principles outlined in the employment contracts, or they may modify vesting schedules or acceleration rights, depending on the negotiated terms. Employees should be attentive to these acquisition-specific terms, as they can significantly impact the ultimate treatment of their unvested RSUs.

During due diligence, acquirers often assess the equity compensation landscape of the target company, including the total number of outstanding RSUs, vesting schedules, and change of control provisions. Understanding these factors can help acquirers plan their integration strategies, negotiate more favorable terms, or structure the acquisition in a way that minimizes the impact of unvested RSUs on the combined entity. Keeping on top of these conversations can help employees assess their equity compensation in the context of the acquisition and make more informed decisions about their future.

AD

Navigating the Acquisition Process: Advice for Employees

Embarking on an acquisition can be an uncertain and anxiety-inducing time for employees, especially when their unvested RSUs are at stake. To help mitigate risks and maximize opportunities, employees should be proactive and well-versed in the key aspects of RSU treatment during an M&A transaction.

Consult with Financial and Legal Professionals

Before making any decisions, employees should consult with a financial advisor or tax professional who specializes in equity compensation and M&A. They can help employees understand the tax implications of different RSU treatment scenarios and provide tailored advice based on their unique financial situation. Additionally, employees should consider working with an employment lawyer to review their employment agreements and negotiate terms that protect their interests in the event of an acquisition.

Communicate Openly with Management

Communication is key during the acquisition process. Employees should maintain open lines of communication with management, asking questions about the acquisition's impact on their employment, equity compensation, and benefits. By staying informed, employees can better adapt to the changing landscape and make more confident decisions about their future.

In a fast-paced tech industry, acquisitions are a fact of life. While the particular treatment of unvested RSUs can vary, understanding the key outcomes and factors at play arms employees with the information they need to navigate the acquisition process with confidence. By staying informed, consulting with professionals, and maintaining open communication with management, employees can help secure the best possible outcome for their unvested RSUs during a merger or acquisition. As you continue your journey in the dynamic world of tech and startups, remember that acquisitions can present exciting opportunities to grow both personally and professionally. By embracing change and remaining adaptable, employees can not only protect their equity compensation but also position themselves for new growth and success in their careers.
AD