What is the Instructional System Design Model?
The instructional system design (ISD) model is a structured approach used by instructional designers to create effective learning experiences. It's akin to a blueprint for developing training programs, guiding educators and trainers through a systematic process to ensure that learning objectives are met.
ISD was first introduced by Systems Development Corporation in the 1970s and has since evolved, with various models emerging, such as Dick & Carey, Kemp, and Successive Approximation. Each model varies in its steps and emphasis, but they all share a common goal: to create instruction that's engaging, relevant, and effective.
Key Components of ISD Models
The core of any ISD model is a series of steps that guide the instructional designer through the process of developing learning materials. These steps, albeit differing in number and name across various models, typically include analyzing learning needs, setting instructional goals, and evaluating the effectiveness of the instruction.
Other components often involve decisions about the learning environment, the use of technology, and the selection of appropriate instructional strategies. These components work together to create a comprehensive and cohesive learning experience.
The Analysis Phase
Every ISD model begins with an analysis of the learning need. This phase involves gathering and scrutinizing information about the learners, the content to be taught, and the context in which the learning will take place. It may include needs assessments, task analyses, and learner analyses.
By the end of this phase, instructional designers should have a clear understanding of what learners currently know, what they need to learn, and the most effective way to teach them. This information is then used to set instructional goals and objectives.
The Design Phase
The design phase is where instructional designers make key decisions about the learning experience. This includes selecting appropriate instructional strategies and learning activities, deciding on the learning environment, and choosing the right mix of media and technology.
During this phase, designers also create prototypes or storyboards of their instruction. These are then reviewed and refined based on feedback, a process known as formative evaluation, which helps ensure that the final product meets the intended learning objectives.
Unique Features of Different ISD Models
While the core components of ISD models are broadly similar, each model has unique features that set it apart. For instance, the Dick & Carey model emphasizes the use of formative evaluation, while the Successive Approximation model encourages an iterative, cyclical approach to design.
Each model also places different emphasis on various aspects of instructional design. Some models focus heavily on the analysis phase, believing that a thorough understanding of the learning need is key to effective instruction. Others focus more on the design and development phases, emphasizing the importance of careful planning and prototyping.
The Dick & Carey Model
The Dick & Carey model, first proposed by Walter Dick and Lombardo Carey in 1978, is one of the most widely used ISD models. It consists of nine steps, starting with analyzing learning needs and ending with evaluating the instruction.
One of the standout features of this model is its emphasis on formative evaluation. Instructional designers using this model are encouraged to continually test and refine their instruction throughout the design process, ensuring that it meets the intended learning objectives.
The Successive Approximation Model
In contrast to linear models like Dick & Carey, the Successive Approximation model, proposed by Smith and Ragan in 1999, takes a more cyclical approach. It encourages instructional designers to repeatedly review and refine their instruction, even after it has been implemented.
This model emphasizes the importance of ongoing feedback and evaluation, not just during the design phase, but throughout the life of the instruction. This allows for continuous improvement, ensuring that the instruction remains relevant and effective over time.
In the world of instructional design, the ISD model serves as a compass, guiding instructional designers through the complex process of creating effective learning experiences. By understanding and applying the principles of ISD, trainers and educators can ensure that their instruction meets the needs of their learners, enabling them to achieve their full potential.