What is Slander & Defamation of Character?
Slander and defamation of character are legal terms that often cause confusion due to their similar meanings and consequences. While both involve making false statements about someone, it's crucial to understand the nuances between them, as well asthe common ground they share. This article explores the definitions, differences, and legal implications of slander, defamation, and character assassination.
The broad term encompassing both slander and defamation is 'defamation of character'. Defamation refers to any false communication, either spoken or written, that harms a person's reputation. It can be in the form of fraudulent accusations which prevent others from associating with the targeted individual, or negatives statements that ridicule, hold up to contempt, or cause financial damage. Now, let's delve deeper into slander and defamation.
Slander: Defamation of Character by Speech
Slander is a form of defamation that involves publishing false statements, either by spoken words (spoken to one or more individuals) or gestures, which cause injury or damage to someone's reputation. It's a type of defamation that is actually spoken, rather than written or otherwise committed to a physical medium.
Slanderous statements, or slander, can be communicated in various ways — through public statements, face-to-face conversations, or even shouted out to a crowd. For instance, falsely accusing someone of a crime or claiming they have a serious infectious disease are common examples of slander.
Proof of Slander
Proving slander in a court of law can be challenging due to the often stringent rules of evidence. Typically, proving slander requires showing that the defendant made the defamatory statement in question, that the statement was made to a third party, and that the statement was false and caused damage or injury to the plaintiff's reputation.
In certain cases, 'actual malice' is required for a public figure to recover damages from a defendant who is not the person who originally made the statement. This means the person making the statement had knowledge of its falsity or acting recklessly regarding its truth or falsity. For private individuals, only negligence in preparing the statement is required.
Slander Per Se
In some situations, spoken defamation is considered so inherently harmful that it is considered 'slander per se'. These are categories of statements that are presumed to cause injury because they naturally injure one's reputation. They include false accusations of committing a serious crime, claiming someone has a communicable disease, accusing someone of being unchaste or unfaithful, or attributing professional misconduct to a professional.
Libel: Written or Published Defamation of Character
Libel, on the other hand, is a form of defamation that is written, printed, or communicated through signs, signals, gestures, or pictures. It can include anything from spoken statements (if committed to a physical medium like audio recording) to written words, social media posts, or even symbolic representations like cartoons. Libel shares many similarities with slander, but the key difference lies in the medium of communication.
In terms of the law, slander and libel are treated differently, not just because of the type of communication, but also due to the standards for liability and the means of proof. However, like slander, libel is considered a "speech" protected under the First Amendment, meaning it enjoys some level of protection under the law, and lawsuits against it must prove 'actual malice' in the case of public figures.
Actual Malice Standard
The U.S. Supreme Court established the 'actual malice' standard of liability for libel in the landmark ruling New York Times v. Sullivan (1964). This standard means that a public official or figure cannot win a libel lawsuit unless they can prove that the defendant made the statement knowing it was false or with reckless disregard to its truth or falsity.
For non-public officials, which is most of the population, it's typically easier to prove libel. In these cases, the plaintiff usually needs to show that the defendant acted negligently in making the false statement.
Permissible Defenses for Defamation
Understanding the defenses to libel and slander is essential. Some of the most common defenses include truth, fair comment, privilege (including fair report privilege), and 'honest opinion'.
For instance, if a defendant can prove the alleged defamatory statement was true, they'd be afforded protection. Fair comment also qualifies as a defense if the statement is a genuine opinion. Situations such as a truthful reporting about public figures or matters of general interest may also serve as valid defenses.
Lastly, while these terms indeed overlap, it's crucial to distinguish between slander and defamation. Recognizing these differences can help individuals better understand their rights and potential remedies if they find themselves in such situations. If you suspect you've been a victim of slander or defamation, consider consulting with a legal professional who can provide tailored advice based on your specific situation and local laws.