What is Slander in New Zealand?
In the realm of law, defamation is a broad term that encompasses both libel and slander. While libel refers to written false statements that harm someone's reputation, slander pertains to spoken or verbal defamation. In New Zealand, the legal framework that governs slander and other forms of defamation can be found within the Defamation Act 1992. But what exactly is slander in New Zealand, and how does it differ from other forms of defamation?
Slander, also known as oral defamation, involves making false statements about someone else, either directly to them or to a third party, which causes that person to suffer harm to their reputation, business, or similar. In NZ, slander is separated into two main categories: slanderous words and slander by gestures. Let's delve into the details of these two types and understand their implications under New Zealand law.
Slanderous Words
Slanderous words, or spoken defamation, is the most common form of slander in NZ. It occurs when someone verbally makes a false statement about another person, intending to harm their reputation. The statement must be made to a third party – not to the person being defamed – as a direct statement to the victim would constitute an assault rather than slander.
The Defamation Act 1992 outlines the elements required to prove slander in NZ courts. To succeed in a claim, the plaintiff must establish the following:
- The statement was made to someone other than the person it concerned.
- The statement identified the plaintiff.
- The statement was false.
- The statement caused, or was likely to cause, serious harm to the plaintiff's reputation.
Temporary Damages
One unique aspect of slander in NZ is the possibility of obtaining temporary damages. Unlike libel, where damages are typically awarded on a final basis, slander cases may result in temporary damages until the trial. This interim injunction can freeze the defendant's assets to ensure that, even if the case is appealed, the plaintiff can still recover damages.
However, it's essential to note that obtaining temporary damages requires a high threshold of proof. The plaintiff must show that there is a strong prima facie case of slander, and that damages are likely to be awarded if the case proceeds to trial. Additionally, the plaintiff must demonstrate that justice requires the grant of an interim injunction to prevent the defendants from dissipating their assets.
Slander by Gestures
Slander by gestures, also known as non-verbal or silent slander, involves making defamatory statements using signs, actions, or other non-verbal communication methods. To constitute slander by gestures, the gesture must be intended to harm the victim's reputation and must be understood as such by the person to whom it is directed. For example, making derogatory hand gestures directed at someone in a public place could potentially be considered slander by gestures if it can be proven that the action was meant to defame the victim.
The same elements required to prove slanderous words also apply to slander by gestures. The plaintiff must establish that the gesture was directed at a third party, identified the plaintiff, was false, and caused, or was likely to cause, serious harm to the plaintiff's reputation.
The Relative Significance of Slander in NZ
In the digital age, slander may not be as prevalent as it once was. Many defamation cases now involve written or visual content shared online. Nevertheless, slander remains an essential area of defamation law, particularly in areas like workplace harassment or public discourse. Understanding the intricacies of slander in NZ is crucial for protecting one's reputation and knowing when to seek legal recourse.
If you find yourself the victim of slander, or if you've been accused of slander, it's essential to seek legal advice promptly. A qualified defamation lawyer can help you navigate the complex landscape of NZ defamation law and protect your rights. Don't let false statements define your reputation or cause harm to your livelihood – take action today and contact a defamation specialist for consultation.