what is the highest scoring game in blue jays history

Highest Scoring Game in Blue Jays History

By Brian King
AD

On April 18, 2016, a night that Toronto Blue Jays fans will never forget, Jose Bautista stepped up to the plate at Rogers Centre, ready to etch his name into the record books. The game against the Boston Red Sox was already filled with tension, tied at 7-7 in the bottom of the 7th inning. But what unfolded was nothing short of extraordinary.

Over the next innings, the Blue Jays scored an astounding 11 runs, fueled by a series of clutch hits, walks, and base-running acumen. Among these was Bautista's legendary bat-flip home run, a moment that would forever be etched in the annals of Blue Jays history. But the run-Scoring dubbed "The 125th Merry-Go-Round" by play-by-play announcer Jerry Howarth, also included a record-breaking RBI single from Kevin Pillar, a bases-clearing double by Josh Donaldson, and a bases-loaded walk to Michael Saunders. As the dust settled, the Blue Jays had shattered franchise records with a monumental 16-run inning.

Setting the Stage

To truly appreciate this feat, one must understand the backdrop. The Blue Jays of the mid-2010s were a team on the rise, fueled by a potent offense and bolstered by the acquisitions of stars like Josh Donaldson and Edwin Encarnacion. By 2016, they were a team hungry for postseason success, a hunger that would make this game all the more meaningful.

AD
the blue jays all - time line up is shown in this poster for their upcoming game
the blue jays all - time line up is shown in this poster for their upcoming game
blue jays
blue jays
blue jays
blue jays

The Red Sox, on the other hand, were perennial rivals, standing in the way of the Blue Jays' playoff aspirations. This game, the third of a four-game series, was a precursor to their intense rivalry, one that would see them clash in the ALDS in each of the next two seasons.

The catalyst: the 7th inning

The rubber match of the series was tense, tied at 2-2 after six innings. A pitching duel between Marcus Stroman and Rick Porcello was shaping up to be a memorable game. But the stage was set to be stolen by the Blue Jays' offense, not their pitchers.

blue jays
blue jays
a baseball player holding a ball in his right hand and pointing to the side with numbers on it
a baseball player holding a ball in his right hand and pointing to the side with numbers on it
blue jays stats
blue jays stats

Leading off the 7th, Darwin Barney singled, sparking a chain reaction that would result in 125 pitches thrown by six Boston pitchers in the inning. It was the longest inning in Major League Baseball history, and a testament to Toronto's tenacity at the plate.

The onslaught

Josh Donaldson opened the floodgates with a two-run double, the first of Toronto's mind-boggling 11 hits in the inning. Edwin Encarnacion followed with an RBI single, and after a run-scoring wild pitch, Russell Martin and Kevin Pillar filled the bases with consecutive walks. It was 6-2 Blue Jays, and the inning was far from over.

AD

Jose Bautista cleared the pins with a majestic three-run blast, his bat-flip becoming an instantly iconic moment. A bases-loaded walk to Michael Saunders, a two-run double from Justin Smoak, and an RBI single from Kevin Pillar later, the Blue Jays had posted an MLB record 16 runs in an inning, more than half of their franchise-record 22 runs scored on the night.

blue jays
blue jays
blue jays stats
blue jays stats
Cubs unsung heroes: Alex Avila, August 20, 2017
Cubs unsung heroes: Alex Avila, August 20, 2017
blue jays
blue jays
blue jays stats
blue jays stats
By the Numbers: An appreciation of Josh Donaldson’s Blue Jays tenure
By the Numbers: An appreciation of Josh Donaldson’s Blue Jays tenure

Aftermath and Legacy

The 16-4 victory, the most lopsided win in franchise history, vaulted the Blue Jays into first place in the AL East. It was a momentum-shift, a statement game that set the stage for their eventual World Series appearance.

The 16-run inning, meanwhile, became a symbol of the team's resilience and offensive prowess. It was a testament to the power of patience at the plate, of aggressive base-running, and of timely hitting. The record, since tied by the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2020, stands as a beacon of what Blue Jays teams can aspire to, a cultural touchstone, and a reminder of the immutable power of baseball's overlooked art: the longball.

AD

As the Blue Jays continue to chase their next championship, they do so with the memory of that night, April 18, 2016, etched into their collective consciousness. And so do their fans, forever reliving the magic of "The 125th Merry-Go-Round", a night that will forever be remembered as the highest-scoring game in Blue Jays history.

toronto blue jays
toronto blue jays
AD