what makes a bad plot twist

What Drives aBad Plot Twist?

By Mark Brown
AD

In the vast landscape of storytelling, the plot twist stands as a towering tree, dramatic and alluring. Yet, not all twists bear the sweet fruit of satisfaction. Some, like rotten apples, leave audiences bewildered and unsatisfied. So, what factors contribute to a bad plot twist? Let's delve into the mechanics of poorly executed twists and understand what makes them fall flat.

Bad plot twists often arise from a mismatch between the setup and the reveal, leaving audiences feeling manipulated rather than amazed. They can detract from the overall narrative, making the viewing or reading experience less enjoyable. By identifying these common pitfalls, we can appreciate what makes a plot twist truly compelling.

Lack of Foreshadowing

A well-crafted plot twist doesn't happen in a vacuum. Its power lies in the seeds planted earlier in the story. When a twist lacks foreshadowing, it seems arbitrary, springing up unexpectedly like a sudden thunderstorm on a sunny day.

AD
Plot Twist Ideas
Plot Twist Ideas
What makes a story badly written, Avoid these mistakes for your next novel part 2
What makes a story badly written, Avoid these mistakes for your next novel part 2
3 Killer Plot Twists in Fiction: And How They Blow Our Minds - TCK Publishing
3 Killer Plot Twists in Fiction: And How They Blow Our Minds - TCK Publishing

The absence of hints or subtle nudges makes the twist feel unearned, leaving the audience questioning why they should invest in its implications. Effective foreshadowing, however, entices the audience to look back and appreciate the smaller details that led to the revelation, enriching their engagement with the story.

Over-reliance on Red Herrings

Red herrings, false leads designed to misdirect, can be an effective tool when used sparingly. However, overusing them can backfire, making the audience suspicious of any hint or clue. In worst-case scenarios, they might 年齛lrbecome deskGNdisabled to the point of apathy, no longer bothering with potential foreshadowing because they don't trust it.

an advertisement with the words plot twist written in black and white, on a white background
an advertisement with the words plot twist written in black and white, on a white background
Plot Twists That Readers Hate
Plot Twists That Readers Hate
18 Plots Twists From TV Shows That Were Incredibly Disappointing
18 Plots Twists From TV Shows That Were Incredibly Disappointing

In such instances, when the big twist arrives, it may fail to astonish because the audience has been conditioned to dismiss or doubt any signposts along the way. Subtly weaving genuine foreshadowing into the narrative fabric thus becomes crucial for a twist's success.

Failure to Integrate with the Story

A poor plot twist can feel tacked on, unrelated to the core narrative, like a bolt from the blue. It rattles around within the story, never fully connecting with the characters or themes. When this happens, the twist's purpose - to challenge our perceptions and deepen our understanding - remains unfulfilled.

AD

To integrate a twist effectively, it should tie into the central conflict, character development, or overall themes. It should provide new insights, resolutions, or raise further questions that warrant reflection. When a twist feels gratuitous or disconnected, it detracts from the story, ultimately leaving a bitter aftertaste.

Plot Twist Ideas to Shock Your Reader
Plot Twist Ideas to Shock Your Reader
Annoying Plot Twist In a Novel | Part 1
Annoying Plot Twist In a Novel | Part 1
Plot twist readers hate! Writing mistakes to Avoid!
Plot twist readers hate! Writing mistakes to Avoid!
Best Plot Twist Books
Best Plot Twist Books
Some of the Most Overused Plot Twists
Some of the Most Overused Plot Twists
Writing inspiration for writing shocking plot twist for your novel
Writing inspiration for writing shocking plot twist for your novel

Logical Loopholes and Inconsistencies

A compelling narrative respects the rules it establishes. A plot twist, therefore, should adhere to those rules, or at least provide a satisfying rationale for breaking them. When it doesn't, the audience may feel cheated, leading to a quick loss of respect for the story.

Damaging inconsistencies can manifest in various ways, such as characters acting out of character, events defying established physics or rules, or information conveniently appearing to service the twist. These issues create cognitive dissonance, leaving viewers or readers uncomfortable and uninterested.

AD

Impossible World-building

World-building is an essential aspect of storytelling. When a twist violates the established world, it can feel arbitrary and nonsensical, ruining suspension of disbelief. For example, introducing teleportation into a story previously founded on physical motion and momentum, then using it as a catalyst for the twist, may leave audiences scratching their heads.

the twitter post has been altered to include two different texts
the twitter post has been altered to include two different texts

While twists may challenge our assumptions, they should still adhere to the rules of their universe. If not, they risk feeling hollow and unsatisfying, like empty promises. A compelling twist should respect and expand on the narrative's internal logic.

Retconning and Handwaving

Retconning, short for 'retroactive continuity,' involves changing past events to fit a new narrative direction. While not inherently bad, it can be problematic when used to force a twist on the story. The danger lies in undermining previous occurrences, making them seem meaningless or falsifying their importance.

AD

Handwaving, conversely, dismisses complexity with vague explanations or magical solutions. It's an easy way to prop up a bad twist but ultimately leaves the audience craving more substance. Both techniques send the message that the original story or its rules didn't matter, which can be disheartening for those who invested emotionally in the tale.

Unsatisfying Resolutions

A twist should ideally spark joy, curiosity, or deep thought. Unfortunately, many fall flat because they offer no resolution or closure, leaving viewers or readers unsatisfied and confused. Even worse, some twists introduce more problems than they solve, muddying the narrative waters.

Ineffective twists often shatter the story without putting it back together. They create paradoxes, pose unanswerable questions, or simply provide new questions that never get addressed. This lack of resolution can feel like a cop-out, leaving the audience yearning for a proper conclusion.

Deus Ex Machina

Derived from Greek theatre, 'deus ex machina' quite literally translates to 'god from the machine.' In storytelling, it refers to an improbable, off-the-wall explanation or event resolving the conflict, often in a contrived or unsatisfying manner. An example could be introducing a previously unmentioned character with a MacGuffin that conveniently solves all problems.

While such twists might provide instant relief from tension, they seldom feel earned or narratively pleasing. They breed contempt, as they often rely on external forces rather than the characters' own abilities or the story's internal mechanics for resolution.

Introducing Unrelated Elements

Some plot twists attempt to shock by introducing completely unrelated elements or events. For instance, revealing a character's preferred brand of toothpaste as the story's crux doesn't connect with the narrative, providing no catharsis or resolution.

Irrelevant information, no matter how shocking or unexpected, feels superfluous and annoying when it fails to serve a purpose. To engage viewers or readers, a twist should relate to the core narrative, not exist merely as a shock value tactic.

In the vast arena of storytelling, the plot twist, when executed poorly, can leave audiences bewildered rather than amazed. By understanding what makes a plot twist bad, we can appreciate the artistry behind a truly compelling reveal - one that respects the story, challenges our perceptions, and leaves us craving more. So, the next time you encounter a twist, look beyond the shock value. Delve deeper and appreciate the craftsmanship that turns mere surprises into unforgettable, emotionally resonant moments.

AD