what makes chicago style pizza different

What Sets Chicago-Style Pizza Apart: Key Differences

By David Walker
AD

Chicago-style pizza, a beloved Windy City specialty, is more than just a delicious pie; it's a unique experience that sets it apart from other pizzas across the country. This deep-dish delight has its roots in Chicago's Italian-American community, dating back to the early 20th century. But what exactly makes Chicago-style pizza stand out from its thin-crusted, Neapolitan, or New York-style counterparts?

A testament to the city's blue-collar roots, Chicago-style pizza is all about abundance and robustness. It's not concerned with subtlety or restraint; it's a hearty, comforting dish that's perfect for sharing among friends and family. But let's dive deeper into the factors that truly set this pizza apart.

Composition of the Crust

At the base of every Chicago-style pizza lies the crust, and this isn't your typical thin and crispy variety. Instead, it's thick, fluffy, and almost cake-like, with a unique corny flavor that comes from the malt in the dough.

AD
What is Chicago Style Pizza? (Why It's So Different!)
What is Chicago Style Pizza? (Why It's So Different!)
Chicago Pizza Styles: 12 Types Explained (Deep Dish, Stuffed, Tavern-Style + More) πŸ•πŸ”₯
Chicago Pizza Styles: 12 Types Explained (Deep Dish, Stuffed, Tavern-Style + More) πŸ•πŸ”₯
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Recipe | Homemade Classic Easy Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Recipe
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Recipe | Homemade Classic Easy Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Recipe

The crust also plays a crucial role in making this pizza a bit of an engineering marvel. Before anything else goes on top, the cheese goes on first, creating a barrier that prevents the sauce from making the crust soggy.

Butter Bombs

Speaking of crust engineering, you can't discuss Chicago-style pizza without mentioning its signature 'butter bomb' technique. In some variations, particularly in restaurant chains like Lou Malnati's, the crust is oiled with a generous helping of sweet creamery butter.

Homemade Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza
Homemade Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza
How Deep Is A Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza?
How Deep Is A Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza?
A Visual Guide to What Makes Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza Great
A Visual Guide to What Makes Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza Great

This not only enhances the flavor but also helps maintain the crust's golden, flaky exterior, even when the pie is served after being stored overnight.

Cheese Blanket

The cheese layer in a Chicago-style pizza is a key part of what makes it unique. Instead of a thin layer mixed in with the toppings, it's a hearty blanket of mozzarella (and sometimes other cheeses) that sits right on top of the crust.

AD

Amidst all the other toppings, it might seem counterintuitive, but this arrangement keeps the cheesy goodness from getting lost or overwhelmed. Plus, it's just pure delight digging into that gooey, cheesy layer with every slice.

Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Recipe | Cheesy Deep Pan Pizza
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza Recipe | Cheesy Deep Pan Pizza
Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza | Sally's Baking Addiction
Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza | Sally's Baking Addiction
five chicago pizza styles with the title text overlaying it in red and white
five chicago pizza styles with the title text overlaying it in red and white
What is Chicago-Style Pizza? Everything You Need to Know
What is Chicago-Style Pizza? Everything You Need to Know
the homemade chicago style deep dish pizza is ready to be cut into slices and served
the homemade chicago style deep dish pizza is ready to be cut into slices and served
the best homemade chicago style pizza with cheese and marinara sauce is on a pan
the best homemade chicago style pizza with cheese and marinara sauce is on a pan

Topping Placement: The Italian Beef of Pizzas

The pie emerges from the oven with a hearty chunk of meaty goodness (usually Italian beef), followed by succulent sausage or pepperoni, and perhaps a medley of peppers. All this sits atop the cheese, with the thick, chunky tomato sauce crowning it all.

This distinct layering is what gives Chicago-style pizza its signature appearance, with a sauce that remains bright red instead of blending into the cheese as in other styles.

AD

Sauce to Jefferey as Pease

Let's talk about that sauce. It's not your typical smooth, impassioned Neapolitan pizza sauce. Instead, it's chunky, robust, and often spiced with a hint of Italian seasoning, sometimes even packing a bit of a kick.

11 Types of Pizza
11 Types of Pizza

Some might argue that the sauce is almost like a minestrone, with pieces of tomato and other vegetables suspended within. But you know what? That just makes it even more delicious, setting it apart from other pizza styles.

Γ¨de and More Toppings

Chicagoans resolve a vertically challenged debate by loading up their pizzas with a variety of toppings. Everything from Italian sausage and mushrooms to onions, green peppers, and more finds its way onto these pies. It's not for the faint-hearted, but it's one of the many things that make Chicago-style pizza so loved.

AD

And let's not forget the option of adding an extra helping of cheese, or a second layer of Italian beef for those feeling extra hungry. After all, as our friends from the Midwest say, β€œWhy settle for less when you can have more?”

The Chicago-style pizza experience is more than just a contest of indulgence. It's about sharing a slice of community, a bit of history, and a whole lot of love for good, hearty food. So, whether you're a fellow Chicagoan or just a curious pizza lover, why not give this Midwestern marvel a try? And who knows, you might just find yourself craving that thick, cheesy, flavor-packed pie again soon.

AD