what was blackbeard's real flag

The Real Flag of Blackbeard: Debunking Pirate Myths

By Steven Johnson
AD

Sailors across the Seven Seas have long wondered about the true identity of the flag unfurled by the infamous pirate known as Blackbeard, who terrorized the waters of the Atlantic during the late 17th and early 18th centuries. The symbol he chose to represent his fearsome reputation has become the stuff of legend and has spawned numerous theories, myths, and even artistic interpretations. Let's delve into the historical record to uncover what was Blackbeard's real flag.

The enigma surrounding Blackbeard's flag can be attributed to the lack of contemporary witnesses describing the flag in detail. The only known description comes from a single source: the deposition of a sailor named Thomas Gordon, taken after Blackbeard's death in 1718. However, even Gordon's account is vague, merely mentioning a black flag with writings in it. This has left the door open for speculation and misinformation.

Blackbeard's Flag as Described by Thomas Gordon

The most reliable account of Blackbeard's flag comes from the deposition of Thomas Gordon, a sailor who was taken prisoner by the pirate in 1717. Gordon recalled seeing a "black flag with writings in it" when they boarded the HMS Scarborough. Intriguingly, Gordon was the only one of Blackbeard's captives to provide a description of the flag, suggesting that it may have been treated as a secret or a distinctive symbol amongst the crew.

AD
Blackbeards Flag Poster
Blackbeards Flag Poster
PirateFlag Blackbeard Flag
PirateFlag Blackbeard Flag
Blackbeard Flag Sticker
Blackbeard Flag Sticker

Gordon's account, however, does not provide the exact meaning or appearance of the "writings" on the flag. This lack of detail has led some historians to believe that the flag may have simply been a solid black color with no additional symbols or words. Others have proposed alternative interpretations, drawing upon legend and folklore.

Mistaken Identifications and Legends

One of the most common misidentifications of Blackbeard's flag is the Jolly Roger, which features a white skull and crossbones on a black background. While this symbol was indeed used by many pirates of the time, there is no contemporary evidence to suggest that Blackbeard used this particular design. In fact, the Jolly Roger was more commonly associated with Blackbeard's quartermaster, Calico Jack Rackham, and other pirates who operated in the Caribbean.

a pirate flag with a skull and crossbones on it, in the background
a pirate flag with a skull and crossbones on it, in the background
an advertisement for coachella and the blackbeard concert in front of a crowd
an advertisement for coachella and the blackbeard concert in front of a crowd
two pirate flags with skull and crossbones on them, one red flag, the other black
two pirate flags with skull and crossbones on them, one red flag, the other black

A more plausible candidate for Blackbeard's flag is the "Davy Jones' Locker" flag, which features a skull or skeleton with a crossbones or a spear passing through it, sometimes with additional details such as an hourglass or a heart. This symbol was often used to represent Davy Jones, the devil of the sea, who was said to control the ocean's depths and whose domain was known as Davy Jones' Locker. Although no contemporary sources confirm that Blackbeard used this flag, its symbolism does align with the pirate's fearsome reputation and the supernatural awe with which he was often regarded.

Artistic Interpretations and Popular Culture

Numerous artists and writers have attempted to visualize Blackbeard's flag based on the scant historical evidence. Some have depicted a simple black flag with a skull or other gruesome symbol, while others have incorporate musical notes, hearts, or other motifs to represent the "writings" mentioned by Gordon. These interpretations may be grasses, but they offer valuable insights into the power and intrigue of Blackbeard's legend.

AD

Popular culture has also contributed to the ongoing debate surrounding Blackbeard's flag. Many films, television shows, and video games depict the pirate waving an ominous black flag, often adorned with bones, skulls, or other dark symbols. These portrayals have further cemented the image of Blackbeard as a fearsome and almost mythical figure, even if they may not accurately reflect the historical reality of his chosen flag.

an old pirate flag with different types of skulls and crossbones on the flags
an old pirate flag with different types of skulls and crossbones on the flags
Stede Bonnet Trial, Stede Bonnet Quotes, Stede Bonnet Regatta Southport, Stede Bonnet Season 2, Stede Bonnet Pirate Flag, Stede Bonnet Portrait, Stede Bonnet With A Beard, Stede Bonnet Flag, Ofmd Headcanons
Stede Bonnet Trial, Stede Bonnet Quotes, Stede Bonnet Regatta Southport, Stede Bonnet Season 2, Stede Bonnet Pirate Flag, Stede Bonnet Portrait, Stede Bonnet With A Beard, Stede Bonnet Flag, Ofmd Headcanons
One of Bartholomew Robert's flafs
One of Bartholomew Robert's flafs
Famous Pirate Flags And Their Meanings - Vispronet
Famous Pirate Flags And Their Meanings - Vispronet
Blackbeard's flag
Blackbeard's flag
a skeleton holding a red heart and an arrow
a skeleton holding a red heart and an arrow

Blackbeard's Reputation and the Symbolism of His Flag

The true significance of Blackbeard's flag lies not in its appearance, but in what it represented - a symbol of defiance, fear, and dread among sailors who plied the waters of the colonial Atlantic. Blackbeard's fearsome reputation was built upon his ferocious presence, his heavily armed ship, and his seemingly supernatural ability to inspire terror in his enemies. His flag would have been a visible manifestation of this power, striking awe into the hearts of all who saw it.

Blackbeard's decision to fly a black flag with "writings" may have been a deliberate attempt to cultivate his mystique and reinforce his fearsome reputation. Without a clear identification mark, plundered ships would have been unable to provide precise details about their attackers, further shrouding Blackbeard and his crew in an aura of mystery and danger. In this way, Blackbeard's flag would have served as more than just a marker of his territory; it would have been a tool in his psychological warfare against his foes.

AD

Blackbeard's Flag as a Symbol of Piracy

Despite the uncertainty surrounding Blackbeard's personal flag, the black flag with its various designs has become a broad symbol of piracy itself. The black flag has come to represent not just a single pirate, but an entire subculture of outlaws who operated beyond the reach of the law. It serves as a powerful visual cue, embodying the rebellious spirit, aggression, and sense of liberation that piracy has long represented in popular culture.

two tweets are on the same page
two tweets are on the same page

Furthermore, the black flag has become an enduring symbol of defiance and non-conformity, inspiring countless individuals and groups to adopt it as their own. From sailors and labor activists to political rebels and punk rockers, the black flag continues to resonate as a powerful statement of resistance and dissent.

Blackbeard's Legacy and the Enduring Appeal of Piracy

The enduring mystique surrounding Blackbeard's flag is a testament to the enduring appeal of the pirate legend. By défying authority and carving out their own path, pirates have become symbols of freedom and rebellion, inspiring countless stories, songs, andreams. Through his larger-than-life persona and reputation, Blackbeard has become one of the most iconic figures in this rich tradition.

AD

In the centuries since Blackbeard's death, the search for the true identity of his flag has captivated historians, artists, and enthusiasts alike. While we may never know the exact appearance of the flag that flew from the mainmast of the Adventure or the Queen Anne's Revenge, the quest to uncover its secrets offers a fascinating glimpse into the world of 18th-century piracy and the power of symbols to shape our understanding of the past.

As we continue to explore the hidden corners of Blackbeard's legend, we are reminded of the enduring allure of the pirate lifestyle. So, fellow buccaneers, raise a glass and hoist the colors - whether it's the Jolly Roger, the "Davy Jones' Locker" flag, or a black flag with its own secret writings, let Blackbeard's spirit live on in our hearts and in the winds of the seven seas.

AD