The Origin Story of Fortune Cookies: Where They Actually Came From
Have you ever wondered about the origins of those crisp, sweet treats that predict your future? Fortune cookies, a staple in American Chinese restaurants, have a fascinating history that's a blend of mystery and intrigue. Let's dive into the question: where did fortune cookies originate?
Believe it or not, the exact origin of fortune cookies is a contentious issue, with two separate claims: one from Japan and another from California. Let's explore both these main topics and attempt to unravel this tasty enigma.
Japanese Origins
The first claim traces back to Japan in the early 1900s. It's believed that fortune cookies were inspired by a traditional Japanese cracker known as 'tsujiura senbei.'
Tsujiura senbei, made from rice, oil, and sugar, was flat and round, much like a fortune cookie. They contained a piece of paper with a fortune or a proverb printed on it. However, unlike fortune cookies, tsujiura senbei weren't served in restaurants but rather sold as street food or given as gifts during New Year's.
Makoto Hira
Makoto Hira, a Japanese immigrant to the U.S., is often credited with introducing the concept of fortune cookies. In the 1920s, Hira ran a Los Angeles-based confectionery and may have been inspired by tsujiura senbei to create his own version for his American customers.
Hira's fortune cookies were more crunchy and crisp than their soft Japanese counterparts. They also came with slips of paper bearing inspirational phrases and lucky numbers, much like the modern fortune cookie. Therefore, some historians argue that Hira's adaptation was the first iteration of the fortune cookie in its current form.
Kyoto’s Last Emperor
Another Japanese connection comes from Kyoto, where a man named Tetsusaburo Ohsawa, also known as 'Kyoto's last emperor,' swore he invented the fortune cookie in 1914. His version, however, was made from rice crackers rather than cookie dough, and he used well-wishes and blessings as his messages.
Although Ohsawa's claim did not gain widespread recognition, it hints at a Japanese origin for these olive-sized treats. Nevertheless, the Fortune Cookie Chronicles author, Jennifer 8. Lee, believes Ohsawa's fortune cookie was merely a precursor and not the predecessor to the cookie we know today.
American Origins
The second claim originates from California in the early 20th century. Two immigrant-owned companies in the U.S., one in Los Angeles and the other in San Francisco, both started selling fortune cookies around the same time.
David Jung, a Chinese-American immigrant and founder of the Hong Kong Noodle Company in Los Angeles, is often credited with creating the fortune cookie. He claimed to have invented it in 1918, though records only confirm sales by 1921. Jung's cookies were made from dough and contained small paper messages bearing encouraging phrases, not unlike Hira's.
Morton Newman
In San Francisco, another contender, Japantown shop owner Morten Newman, started selling a 'fortune tea cake' in 1914. These were small, oblong cookies with messages tucked inside. However, Newman's claim is fraught with controversy, as World War II visa records show he arrived in the U.S. in 1922, four years after he claimed to have invented the fortune cookie.
Despite this discrepancy, Newman's story gained traction due to a promotional campaign by the fortune cookie company Fugetsu Confectionery. They popularized the notion that Newman was the inventor, even publishing a "historic" photograph of Newman holding a fortune cookie. Yet, this image has since been proven to be a composite, further casting doubt on Newman's involvement.
U.S. Patent
Adding to the confusion, a U.S. patent was granted in 1983 to a Japanese-American man named Edward och isotropic, who alleged he invented the fortune cookie in 1958. However, this runs contrary to the earlier claims from both Japan and the U.S.
The patent, however, is seen more as a legal move for copyright protection rather than a declaration of origin. It's widely believed that the fortune cookie evolved over time and through multiple iterations, with various influences from Japan and the U.S.
As for the final word on the matter, it seems we may never know for certain where fortune cookies originated. Each side presents compelling evidence, yet each also has its share of contradictions and uncertainties. So, the next time you crack open a fortune cookie, savor the mystery along with its sweet taste and take the predicted future with a grain of salt – or perhaps a dash of soy sauce.