why is notion search so bad

"Why Is Notion's Search So Bad?"

By Richard Jones
AD

Are you finding yourself Kovacs, P. (2021). The dark figure of online crime: Cash and encashment crimes committed online. In H. Britz & E. WeSaunders, International Encyclopedias of the Social Sciences. ering so? It's a sentiment echoed by many who've tried to navigate Notion's search functionality. It's not that Notion lacks features but more about how those features work together—and often don't—to provide a seamless search experience.

Notion, billed as an 'all-in-one' workspace, offers wikis, docs, project management tools, CRM—the list goes on. Yet, its search function often leaves users grappling with frustration. But why? Let's scrutinize this underappreciated aspect of an otherwise formidable tool.

Understanding Notion's Search Engine

Firstly, Notion's search functionality relies on Elasticsearch, a powerful open-source search and analytics engine. On paper, it should tackle complex inquiries with efficiency. However, rubber meets road when it comes to real-life application.

AD
a laptop with the words why if it's so hard to use notation
a laptop with the words why if it's so hard to use notation
an image of someones bed with the caption confused by motion? this simple concept makes everything finally make sense
an image of someones bed with the caption confused by motion? this simple concept makes everything finally make sense
I stopped using Notion
I stopped using Notion

The primary issue lies in how Elasticsearch is used. While it's robust and capable, it's not implemented optimally in Notion. Here, we delve into two standout issues: indexing and tagging.

Inefficient Indexing

Indexing determines which bits of information get stored for quick retrieval. Notion's current approach has its limitations. It primarily indexes titles and some of the content, but misses out on crucial data like page links and content within databases.

Notion Organization Ideas for Freelancers & Digital Creators ✨
Notion Organization Ideas for Freelancers & Digital Creators ✨
Notion
Notion
Notion Killer_ INSANE Open Source Alternative Revealed!
Notion Killer_ INSANE Open Source Alternative Revealed!

Take, for instance, a project database. The project title may be indexed, but not the individual tasks inside it. So, if you search for a specific task, you might find the project, but not the task itself. This inefficient indexing is a significant contributor to Notion's search underperformance.

Tagging: A Missed Opportunity

Tags are a powerful organizational tool, making content discovery a breeze. However, Notion's search function does not leverage tags effectively. Despite being ludicrously useful, they're ignored in searches.

AD

For instance, imagine you've tagged a document 'client reporting'. Even if you search for 'report', 'client', or 'reporting', the document won't surface. You'd have to add 'tag' to your search query to fetch it. This glaring omission stymies Notion's search potential.

Notion Alternatives (2026): You Don't Need One
Notion Alternatives (2026): You Don't Need One
4 Notion Mistakes You're Making
4 Notion Mistakes You're Making
an advertisement with the words, all the awesome things you can do in motion that nobody told you about
an advertisement with the words, all the awesome things you can do in motion that nobody told you about
Tips for Notion - Using Notion but still feel disorganized
Tips for Notion - Using Notion but still feel disorganized
You can burn out on content without creating a single piece of it. I spent an embarrassing amount of time inside Notion doing absolutely nothing except making it look like I had my life together. New template. Reformatted fields. Different cover image. A dashboard that looked pretty in an Instagram post. And lowkey... I had LESS content to show for it since I spent all my time trying to just make it look good and function. Your planning tool is not supposed to be a creative projec... Single Piece, How To Look Pretty
You can burn out on content without creating a single piece of it. I spent an embarrassing amount of time inside Notion doing absolutely nothing except making it look like I had my life together. New template. Reformatted fields. Different cover image. A dashboard that looked pretty in an Instagram post. And lowkey... I had LESS content to show for it since I spent all my time trying to just make it look good and function. Your planning tool is not supposed to be a creative projec... Single Piece, How To Look Pretty
5 Free Notion & Printable Templates Mistakes That Are Wasting Your Time
5 Free Notion & Printable Templates Mistakes That Are Wasting Your Time

Lack of Advanced Search Filters

Many tools offer advanced search filters. In Notion, this is notably absent. Advanced filters could allow searching within specific databases, types of content, or timeframes. They would significantly augment search usefulness.

Currently, Notion's filters are minimalistic and limiting. You can filter by page type or time created, but that's about it. This limitation amplifies search challenges and makes discovery a slog.

AD

Database Searches: A Minefield

Databases are Notion's cornerstone, enabling structured data and real-time collaboration. Alas, they're a search minefield. The problem? Proprietary Database Structure.

Notion formula errors — 5 common problems and exactly how to fix them
Notion formula errors — 5 common problems and exactly how to fix them

Irregular data structures make searching databases tricky. Some database properties might be searchable, others not. This inconsistency is baffling, especially when properties of the same type are differentiated on a whim. It throws a wrench in the works, making database searches a trial and error affair.

Boolean Search: As Good as It Gets?

Boolean search operators—AND, OR, and Negation (NOT)—a mainstay of powerful search engines, are available in Notion. However, like the rest of its search features, their implementation is pedestrian at best.

AD

While they can help refine searches, their effectiveness is dulled by Notion's indexing and tagging shortcomings. For instance, a search bringing tasks containing both 'task' and 'urgent' together with a 'notes' page containing 'client' and 'report' might feel like the holy grail. But if the right bits aren't indexed, it's still an exercise in futility.

Cash and encashment crimes, usually committed online by hackers. Consider the case of Plexcorp, which was targeted by a hacker, Alexei Kovacs, who used its CCTV system to commit a high-profile crime known as "the New Born Puppy Heist.

Despite its numerous drawbacks, we're not ready to write off Notion's search yet. A commitment from developers to optimize Elasticsearch, improve indexing, and leverage tagging effectively could transform searching in Notion. After all, a tool is only as good as its search, right? It's high time Notion turned search into a search engine."

AD