Why was Raise the Red Lantern Banned in China
The 1991 film "Raise the Red Lantern" (DA HONG DENG LONG GUA HAO YE) directed by Zhang Yimou faced a peculiar fate in its home country of China, where it was initially banned and later re-released with cuts. This intriguing cinema history begs the question: Why was "Raise the Red Lantern" banned in China?
The film, set in the 1920s, tells the story of a young woman, Songlian, who becomes a concubine to a wealthy man and navigates the complex dynamics among the man's other concubines. Its exploration of gender roles, power structures, and societal norms in pre-revolutionary China appeared to strike a chord with censorship authorities.
The Political Context of the Ban
In the early 1990s, China was still grappling with the aftermath of the Tiananmen Square protests, and the government maintained a tight grip on media and cultural outputs. The film's themes of domestic strife, female disempowerment, and social inequities may have been deemed too sensitive by the censors.
Moreover, the film was produced independently, a rarity at the time, and Zhang Yimou's willingness to tackle provocative themes openly was seen as a challenge to the state's control over cultural production.
URNing the Wrath of the Communist Party
"Raise the Red Lantern" premiered at the Berlin Film Festival, where it won the Silver Bear, earning international acclaim but further raising the ire of Chinese authorities. The Communist Party viewed the film's critical portrayal of returned Nobel laureate Liu Xiaobo as a personal affront, contributing to the ban's severity.
Furthermore, the film's exploration of corruption and abuse of power within the family, which could be extrapolated to dénoncer societal ills, was deemed subversive by the Party.
Sexual Content and Aesthetics
The film's sensual and atmospheric visual storytelling, along with its depiction of sexual dynamics among the concubines, likely played a role in the ban. China's film code strictly prohibits "indecent" content, and the film's exploration of female desire and agency may have been seen as crossing this line.
Zhang Yimou's signature use of vibrant colors and cinematic language, which contributed to the film's global success, may also have been viewed unfavorably by Chinese censors, who prioritize more naturalistic and didactic aesthetics.
The Ban's Aftermath and Re-release
In 1993, "Raise the Red Lantern" was re-released in China with significant cuts, including scenes of sexual content and any explicit references to Liu Xiaobo. Zhang Yimou was subsequently forced to adhere to government-dictated guidelines for his future films, marking a pivotal moment in his career and the broader landscape of Chinese cinema.
The re-release signalled a shift in Chinese film policy, acknowledging the potential box office success of controversial titles while maintaining control over their content.
Censorship's Impact on Chinese Cinema
The ban on "Raise the Red Lantern" was not an isolated incident but part of a broader pattern of censorship that has shaped the trajectory of Chinese cinema. From the "Spiritual Pollution" campaign in the 1980s to the recent crackdown on dissenting voices, filmmakers have had to navigate complex and evolving parameters to maintain artistic autonomy.
However, as Chinese cinema gains global prominence, the tension between censorship and creative expression remains a compelling and producers continue to push boundaries while working within the system.
Today, "Raise the Red Lantern" is celebrated as a seminal work of Chinese cinema, and its enduring controversy underscores the complex interplay between art, politics, and censorship in China. As audiences worldwide continue to appreciate its unique storytelling and visual power, the film stands as a testament to the enduring spirit of Chinese cinema in the face of adversity.