why would you not use a histogram

Why Opt For Alternatives Over Histograms: A Comprehensive Look

By Melissa Jackson
AD

Are you a budding data skeptic questioning the necessity of histograms in data analysis? You're not alone. Despite being a staple in visualizing and understanding distributions, histograms do have their limitations and certain scenarios where alternative graphical methods might prove more beneficial. Let's delve into why you might choose not to use histograms.

Histograms, by their very nature, need to make assumptions – notably about the bin size. Choosing an inappropriate bin size can lead to a distorted representation of the data. So, let's explore when you might want to steer clear of histograms.

When Binning Might Not Serve Your Purpose

Histograms divide your data into bins, which can be advantageous for smoothing out noise and identifying patterns. However, this binning process can also mask important details and lead to loss of information. Let's explore two scenarios where binning might not serve your purpose.

AD
How to Read a Histogram in Photography | Never Lose Highlights or Shadows Again (2026)
How to Read a Histogram in Photography | Never Lose Highlights or Shadows Again (2026)
Beginners Learning To Use The Histogram
Beginners Learning To Use The Histogram
How to read a histogram and why it’s not perfect
How to read a histogram and why it’s not perfect

Loss of Individual Data Points

Histogram binning squeezes your data into groups, which can result in the loss of individual data points. This might not be ideal when you're analyzing a data set with small size or rare events. Individual data points might hold significant information, and grouping them might lead to loss of such critical details.

Imagine you're analyzing a data set of animal heights to identify rare breeds. While a histogram would smoothly show the general distribution, it might lump the outlier data points, missing potential insights about these unique species.

Histogram in Images & Learn a Histogram • PhotoTraces
Histogram in Images & Learn a Histogram • PhotoTraces
How to Read and Use the Histogram in Lightroom and in Your Camera
How to Read and Use the Histogram in Lightroom and in Your Camera
the anatomy of a histogram on a black and white background with words below it
the anatomy of a histogram on a black and white background with words below it

Distortion of Data Distribution

Choosing an inappropriate bin size can lead to a distorted representation of your data. Too many bins can show lots of detail but might overcomplicate the plot, while too few bins can oversimplify the plot and hide important details.

A prime example is when your data is skewed or tail-heavy. A poorly chosen bin size might make your histogram suggest a normal distribution, leading you to draw incorrect conclusions about your data.

AD

A Histogram's Limitations When Representing Multivariate Data

Histograms are great for one-dimensional data. However, when it comes to multivariate data, they quickly hit their limits. Here are two instances when you should consider alternative visualizations.

How To Use The Histogram To Capture Better Photos
How To Use The Histogram To Capture Better Photos
HISTOGRAM Explained: Use it for Perfectly Exposed Photos (VIDEO)
HISTOGRAM Explained: Use it for Perfectly Exposed Photos (VIDEO)
Photography Tips: Understanding a Camera's Histogram and How It Works
Photography Tips: Understanding a Camera's Histogram and How It Works
Understanding the Histogram and Why It's Important
Understanding the Histogram and Why It's Important
an image of some water and trees in the background with text that reads colors and combined rgb histograms
an image of some water and trees in the background with text that reads colors and combined rgb histograms
Photography cheat sheet: How to read a histogram
Photography cheat sheet: How to read a histogram

Loss of Inter-Dimensional Relationships

In cases where your variable interactions are crucial, histograms might fall short. They only display one dimension at a time, obscuring the relationships between variables. For instance, when analyzing customer data for a marketing campaign, being aware of how age interacts with income is crucial. Histograms can't display these interdependencies effectively.

Alternatively, scatter plots, parallel coordinate plots, or pair plots can show these multidimensional relationships clearly, compensating for the limitation in histograms.

AD

Categorical or Mixed Data

Histograms are typically used with continuous numerical data. However, in the data scientific world, you'll often encounter categorical or mixed data. Here, histograms might not be the best tool. Categorical data need to be binned differently, often resulting in an unhelpful visualization.

three different types of mountains with the names and numbers on them, labeled in red
three different types of mountains with the names and numbers on them, labeled in red

In such cases, bars or pie charts might be more suitable for categorical data, while mosaic plots or parallel coordinate plots can handle mixed data effectively.

As a data professional, it's crucial to understand that different graphical methods serve different purposes. While histograms are a powerful tool, they're not the end-all, be-all of data visualization. The goal is to pick the right tool for the right job, aiding understanding and fostering informed decisions. So, the next time you're pondering which chart to use, remember, sometimes not using a histogram can be the best choice!

AD
AD