america's test kitchen macaroni and cheese

America's Test Kitchen Ultimate Macaroni & Cheese

By Kevin Miller
AD

Is there anyone who doesn't love macaroni and cheese? It's a timeless comfort food that's been a staple in American households for generations. But what if we told you that you could elevate this classic dish to a whole new level? Enter America's Test Kitchen, the beloved culinary institution known for its rigorous testing and innovative techniques, which has transformed the humble mac and cheese into a sophisticated and satisfies dish.

The secret to America's Test Kitchen's macaroni and cheese lies in their methodical approach to cooking. They don't just rely on a simple cheese sauce recipe; instead, they conduct extensive research and testing to ensure every element of the dish is perfect. From the type of cheese to the cooking method, they leave no stone unturned in their quest for the ultimate mac and cheese. Let's dive into the key elements that make America's Test Kitchen macaroni and cheese a standout dish.

Mastering the Cheese Sauce

Cheese sauce is the base of any good macaroni and cheese, and America's Test Kitchen has developed a foolproof method for creating a creamy, smooth, and utterly delicious sauce. Their secret? A combination of whole milk and heavy cream, plus a unique process of slowly heating the dairy while adding cheese gradually.

AD
America’s Test Kitchen Mac and Cheese Recipe | Phoenix Cooks
America’s Test Kitchen Mac and Cheese Recipe | Phoenix Cooks
Classic Macaroni and Cheese | America's Test Kitchen
Classic Macaroni and Cheese | America's Test Kitchen
Classic Macaroni and Cheese | America's Test Kitchen
Classic Macaroni and Cheese | America's Test Kitchen

The key is to avoid scorching the milk, which can lead to a grainy texture. To achieve this, ATK recommends using an instant-read thermometer to monitor the temperature, ensuring it reaches 180°F before adding the cheese. This technique encourages the proteins in the milk to bond with the proteins in the cheese, creating a velvety consistency. Additionally, ATK favors a blend of cheddar and Gruyère for their rich, complex flavor and excellent melting properties.

Choosing the Right Cheese

Cheddar is a popular choice for mac and cheese due to its sharp taste and meltability. However, America's Test Kitchen takes it up a notch by combining it with Gruyère. This Swiss cheese adds a nutty, savory note that complements the tanginess of the cheddar, creating a more sophisticated flavor profile.

a bowl of macaroni and cheese next to a pot of pasta on a table
a bowl of macaroni and cheese next to a pot of pasta on a table
How to Make Simple Stovetop Mac and Cheese
How to Make Simple Stovetop Mac and Cheese
Macaroni and Cheese Mix | America's Test Kitchen
Macaroni and Cheese Mix | America's Test Kitchen

ATK's rigorous testing has found an optimal ratio of cheeses for the perfect balance of flavor. They recommend a 2:1 ratio of cheddar to Gruyère for a robust yet harmonious cheese sauce. Using pre-grated cheese is a no-no, as the added starchy ingredients can hinder melting. Instead, grate your cheese from a block for the best results.

Creating the Perfect Béchamel

Béchamel sauce forms the foundation of America's Test Kitchen's cheese sauce. This classic French sauce, made from butter, flour, and milk, creates a smooth base that helps distribute the cheese evenly throughout the dish. ATK's method involves slowly simmering the béchamel to drive off excess water, resulting in a thicker, richer sauce that can accommodate the cheese without becoming grainy.

AD

To create the perfect béchamel, ATK suggests melting butter over medium heat and whisking in an equal amount of flour to form a roux. Slowly pouring in the milk while continuously whisking prevents lumps from forming. The key to a smooth, velvety sauce is patience; allow the mixture to simmer for about 20 minutes, stirring occasionally, until it thickens and the raw flour taste dissipates.

Stovetop Mac and Cheese
Stovetop Mac and Cheese
Grown-Up Stovetop Macaroni and Cheese | Julia At Home (S4 E6)
Grown-Up Stovetop Macaroni and Cheese | Julia At Home (S4 E6)
a bowl filled with macaroni and cheese on top of a table next to a spoon
a bowl filled with macaroni and cheese on top of a table next to a spoon
Baked macaroni and cheese - ATK
Baked macaroni and cheese - ATK
How to Make Creamy Mac and Cheese | America's Test Kitchen
How to Make Creamy Mac and Cheese | America's Test Kitchen
Why American Cheese Makes the Best (and Easiest) Mac and Cheese | What's Eating Dan?
Why American Cheese Makes the Best (and Easiest) Mac and Cheese | What's Eating Dan?

The Best Macaroni for Mac and Cheese

Pasta selection might seem insignificant, but it can significantly impact your dish's overall texture and flavor. America's Test Kitchen has tested numerous pasta shapes and types to find the best fit for their mac and cheese. Their top choice? Small, ridged elbow macaroni. Here's why:

Small elbow pasta has a high surface area to volume ratio, allowing it to trap more cheese sauce and balance the richness. The ridged texture adds extra surface area for more sauce adhesion. Additionally, ATK favors semolina pasta for its slightly firm, rustic texture, which stands up well to the creamy sauce without becoming too soft or mushy. They also recommend undercooking the pasta by about two minutes to ensure it doesn't become overcooked once baked.

AD

Pasta Cooking Techniques

To achieve the perfect cooked pasta for their mac and cheese, America's Test Kitchen uses a combination of toasting and cold-to-hot water shocking methods. Toasting the dry pasta in a preheated oven imparts a nutty flavor and helps the outer layers of the pasta to become slightly firmer, ensuring they maintain a satisfying bite even after being baked in the casserole.

a blue bowl filled with macaroni and cheese on top of a white table
a blue bowl filled with macaroni and cheese on top of a white table

After toasting, ATK plunges the pasta into cold water to halt the cooking process, shocking it and causing it to tighten. Then, they cook the shocked pasta in boiling water for a shorter time than if cooking it traditionally. This results in a pasta that's well-cooked but firm, with a satisfying bite that stands up to the rich, creamy sauce.

Assemblimg and Baking

With the cheese sauce and pasta prepared, it's time to assemble and bake America's Test Kitchen's macaroni and cheese. ATK recommends tossing the cooked pasta with the cheese sauce while both are still hot to ensure even distribution. Then, transfer the mixture to a greased baking dish and sprinkle additional cheese, such as Parmesan or breadcrumbs, on top for extra flavor and crispness.

AD

Baking the casserole at a high temperature (around 425°F) helps create a golden, bubbly cheese crust while ensuring the inside stays creamy. ATK also suggests covering the dish with foil for the first part of the baking process to prevent the top from browning too quickly. Once the internal temperature reaches 160°F, you can remove the foil and broil the top briefly for a delightful, meltingly crisp crust.

As you sink your fork into a perfect bite of America's Test Kitchen macaroni and cheese, you'll understand why this rendition has become a classic. The creamy, rich cheese sauce, the tender yet firm pasta, and the crispy top all combine to create a symphony of flavors and textures that celebrate the humble mac and cheese. So, next time you're craving comfort food, don't skimp on the effort – make it count with America's Test Kitchen's mac and cheese. Your taste buds will thank you!

AD