america's test kitchen macaroni salad

America's Test Kitchen Perfect Macaroni Salad

By John Young
AD

If there's one dish that screams "All-American," it might just be Macaroni Salad. This classic side dish has been loved by generations, and nowhere is its perfection more apparent than in the recipes crafted by America's Test Kitchen. Let's delve into the world of America's Test Kitchen Macaroni Salad, exploring the secret to their creamy, tangy, and utterly satisfying take on this quintessential summer staple.

The key to understanding the allure of America's Test Kitchen Macaroni Salad lies in their commitment to scientific cooking. They've spent countless hours in the test kitchen, painstakingly testing ingredients, techniques, and equipment to ensure their recipes are foolproof and consistently delicious.

The Perfect Pasta

At the heart of any macaroni salad is, well, the macaroni. America's Test Kitchen swears by elbow macaroni, and not just any elbow macaroni. Their tests revealed that medium-size elbows provide the ideal balance of pasta to dressing, while also creating crevices that hold the dressing beautifully.

AD
Macaroni Salad with Buttermilk and Fresh Herbs | America's Test Kitchen
Macaroni Salad with Buttermilk and Fresh Herbs | America's Test Kitchen
Cool and Creamy Macaroni Salad | America's Test Kitchen
Cool and Creamy Macaroni Salad | America's Test Kitchen
Macaroni Salad with Sharp Cheddar and Chipotle | America's Test Kitchen
Macaroni Salad with Sharp Cheddar and Chipotle | America's Test Kitchen

But it's not just about shape. The type of pasta matters too. ATK found that alkaline pasta, made with durum wheat semolina flour, holds its texture better than traditional pasta made from soft wheat flour. This means your macaroni salad won't turn to mush as it sits in the dressing, even on the hottest summer day.

The Ideal Cooking Method

When it comes to cooking the pasta, undercooking is the key. America's Test Kitchen recommends cooking the elbow macaroni until it's just al dente. This ensures that the pasta doesn't become too soft and lose its texture in the dressing. Draining the pasta thoroughly is also crucial, as excess water can dilute the dressing and make the salad watery.

How to Make Our Favorite Macaroni Salad
How to Make Our Favorite Macaroni Salad
a bowl filled with pasta salad on top of a table
a bowl filled with pasta salad on top of a table
Easy Macaroni Salad
Easy Macaroni Salad

Additionally, while many recipes call for rinsing the pasta under cold water, ATK argues that this rinsing step doesn't significantly cool the pasta and can actually remove some of the pasta's starchy coating, which helps the dressing adhere. Instead, they suggest spreading the hot, drained pasta on a baking sheet and tossing it every 5 minutes for about 20 minutes. This allows the pasta to dry and cool gently, locking in its texture and flavor.

The Creamy Dressing

No macaroni salad would be complete without its creamy dressing. America's Test Kitchen combines mayonnaise and sour cream to achieve their dreamy dressing. The mayonnaise provides richness, while the sour cream offers tang and creaminess without added fat. To boost the flavor, they whisk in a touch of vinegar, sugar, and salt, creating a perfectly balanced dressing that complements rather than overwhelming the pasta.

AD

But the key to their dressing isn't just the ingredients; it's also the method. ATK encourages making the dressing in advance and letting it sit in the refrigerator for at least an hour before combining it with the pasta. This allows the flavors to meld and intensify, resulting in a dressed-up dressing that doesn't require any last-minute flavour boosts.

How to Make Our Favorite Macaroni Salad
How to Make Our Favorite Macaroni Salad
macaroni
macaroni
For the Very Best Macaroni Salad, Overcook the Pasta | Julia At Home (S5 E5)
For the Very Best Macaroni Salad, Overcook the Pasta | Julia At Home (S5 E5)
a pink bowl filled with macaroni and cheese next to a spoon on top of a table
a pink bowl filled with macaroni and cheese next to a spoon on top of a table
Crowd-Pleasing Classic Hawaiian Macaroni Salad Recipe
Crowd-Pleasing Classic Hawaiian Macaroni Salad Recipe
Warning: This Macaroni Salad is Seriously Addictive! 🤤🔥
Warning: This Macaroni Salad is Seriously Addictive! 🤤🔥

Assembly and Mix-ins

Once your pasta and dressing are ready, it's time to assemble your masterpiece. America's Test Kitchen recommends tossing the slightly cooled pasta with about half of the dressing, then letting it sit for about 30 minutes. This allows the pasta to soak up some of the dressing and ensures even coating.

Now it's time to add your mix-ins. ATK sticks with classic choices like diced celery, onions, and bell peppers, but they also suggest swapping in grilled corn and fresh herbs for a modern twist. The key is to choose mix-ins that add crunch, color, and extra flavor, but aren't so overwhelming that they distract from the star of the show: the pasta and dressing.

AD

Serving and Storing

Macaroni salad is a versatile dish that's perfect for picnics, potlucks, and just about any summer gathering. America's Test Kitchen recommends serving it chilled or at room temperature, but never hot. After all, there's nothing worse than a soggy, warm macaroni salad.

Amish Macaroni Salad
Amish Macaroni Salad

When it comes to storing, ATK suggests that macaroni salad is best made a day in advance, as this allows the flavors to meld and the pasta to absorb the dressing. However, they also warn that macaroni salad doesn't hold up well for more than three days, as the pasta can become too soft and the dressing too watery.

So there you have it: the secrets to America's Test Kitchen's perfect Macaroni Salad. Whether you're a seasoned cook or a first-time pasta salad maker, their scientific approach and careful attention to detail promise a creamy, tangy, and utterly satisfying macaroni salad that's sure to become a summer staple in your household. Happy cooking!

AD
AD