Are Old Ivory Piano Keys Valuable?
Have you recently inherited or acquired an old piano with ivory keys and wondered, "Are old ivory piano keys worth anything?" The answer is a resounding yes, but knowing their value involves delving into history, understanding regulations, and appreciating the artistry behind these precious materials. Let's explore the world of antique ivory piano keys and unravel their worth.
Ivory's unique properties – translucency, distinct grain patterns, and warmth – have made it a desirable material for piano keys since the 18th century. Renowned piano manufacturers like Steinway & Sons, Blüthner, and Bechstein used ivory extensively due to its durability, texture, and ability to transfer sound unimpeded. But time, laws, and ethical considerations have altered ivory's role in piano-making. So, where does this leave old ivory piano keys in terms of value?
Understanding the History and Rarity of Ivory Piano Keys
Ivory piano keys were initially sourced from various species, including hippopotamus, walrus, and narwhal. However, elephant ivory dominated due to its size, uniformity, and superior tonal qualities. As concerns over elephant populations grew, several countries banned the sale of ivory. In 1989, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) restricted international ivory sales, and the U.S. banned domestic ivory trading in 1990.
Today, it's illegal to sell or manufacture new pianos with raw ivory keys. Existing pianos with ivory keys hold historical and artistic significance, making them scarce and valuable. The combination of age, craftsmanship, and rarity contributes to the worth of old ivory piano keys.
Pre-ban Era Pianos: A Treasure Trove of Ivory Keys
Pianos produced before the 1980s and '90s ivory bans are sought-after for their original ivory keys. These instruments can fetch high prices at auctions and among collectors. For instance, a 1910 Steinway & Sons Model D grand piano with its original ivory keys sold for over $130,000 in 2019. The piano's age, provenance, and ivory keys significantly contributed to its value.
Key factors determining the worth of pre-ban era pianos include the manufacturer's reputation, piano model, overall condition, and, of course, the presence of original ivory keys. Pianos from renowned manufacturers like Steinway, Steingraeber & Søn, and Bösendorfer with pristine, undamaged ivory keys can command higher prices.
Restored and Refinished Pianos: Ivory Keys' Role in Upscaling Value
Pianos with damaged or worn-out ivory keys might undergo restoration or refinishing projects to replace or repair them. For collectors and enthusiasts, the presence of old ivory keys, even when restored, can increase a piano's value. New ivory keys can be purchased legally, provided they're derived from pre-ban stocks or approved non-elephant species. However, authentic old ivory keys retain a higher value and desirability.
Professionally refinished or restored pianos with authentic old ivory keys can command a premium in the market. For example, a restored 1920s Mason & Hamlin Model AA grand piano with reconstructed ivory keys sold for around $80,000 in 2021. The piano's age, restoration quality, and the use of old ivory keys played a significant role in its selling price.
The Ethics and Legality of Trading Old Ivory Piano Keys
시다Prior to investing in or purchasing pianos with ivory keys, it's crucial to understand the ethical and legal implications. Trading raw ivory andproducts derived from elephant populations is strictly prohibited under international law. However, old ivory piano keys/key sets are exempt from these regulations, as they're considered antiques and can be traded within specific guidelines:
- They must be pre-ban and accompanying a pre-ban piano or standalone ivory product.
- No modification, alteration, or repair using new ivory material is allowed.
- Domestic and international trade must be documented to prove their pre-ban origin.
CITES Article 3 Exception: Antique Ivory Piano Keys
CITES Article 3 defines "antique" as an item manufactured before the CITES convention's entry into force on July 1, 1975. Thus, old ivory piano keys manufactured before this date can be traded among signatory countries (excluding certain nations with zero-tolerance policies) following specific regulations. It's essential to obtain written assurance from the seller and other relevant documents certifying the ivory's pre-ban origin.
Nonetheless, the legality and ethical implications vary across countries and regions. Some countries prohibit private ownership and trading of antique ivory, including piano keys, to preserve elephant populations and preserve cultural heritage. It's crucial to research and understand the local laws and ethical considerations before trading old ivory piano keys.
Alternatives to Ivory: Modern Materials and Conservation
The piano industry has embraced alternative materials to replace ivory, including plastics (e.g., acrylic), wood, and even materials derived from animal-friendly byproducts like bone and horn. Some piano manufacturersalso offer services to replace ivory keys with approved materials during restorations.
Moreover, organizations like the Performing Arts FortIFIED (PAF) initiative promote the preservation and responsible restoration of historic pianos. They encourage retaining original ivory keys, provided they comply with regulations and ethical considerations, as they contribute to the instrument's historical value, authenticity, and cultural significance.
In the ever-evolving landscape of piano appreciation and conservation, old ivory piano keys maintain their allure and value. For collectors, enthusiasts, and musicians, these keys serve as distillations of artistry, history, and craftsmanship. By understanding their worth, appreciating their unique qualities, and embracing responsible ownership, we can ensure these timeless works of art continue to enchant us and transcend generations.