ivory used for piano keys

Ivory vs. Plastic: The History and Alternatives of Piano Keys

By Andrew Jones
AD

For centuries, piano keys have been crafted from a variety of materials, but none have been as coveted or controversial as ivory. This natural resource, sourced primarily from the tusks of elephants, has been used extensively in piano manufacturing due to its unique properties. However, as our understanding of environmental and animal welfare issues has evolved, so too has the Piano industry's approach to ivory.

Ivory's allure lies in its creamy white color, durability, and exceptional tactile quality. It provides a smooth, responsive touch that pianist's adore, and it withstands the rigors of constant usage. Yet, this admiration for ivory has come at a devastating cost to elephant populations worldwide.

Ivory's Role in Piano History

The use of ivory in piano keys dates back to the late 18th century, coinciding with the invention of the modern piano. It was initially preferred for its striking color and consistency, which offered improvements over earlier materials like bone and wood. Ivory's premium status was further cemented as it became a symbol of wealth and privilege.

AD
Set of "Ivory" & Ebony Piano Keys, 88 Keys
Set of "Ivory" & Ebony Piano Keys, 88 Keys
Ivory Piano Wall Art, Sculpture par Oleg Degtyarenko | ArtMajeur
Ivory Piano Wall Art, Sculpture par Oleg Degtyarenko | ArtMajeur
Ivory Keys or Plastic Keys?
Ivory Keys or Plastic Keys?

A typical piano keyboard requires up to 88 individual keys, each intricately crafted from a single tusk. This scale of demand has had a profound impact on elephant populations, making it a significant factor in the decline of these majestic creatures.

Elephant Poaching and the Ivory Trade

The demand for ivory has fueled a tragic cycle of poaching and smuggling, with an estimated 20,000 elephants killed each year for their tusks. The illegal ivory trade is now deemed a significant threat to the survival of elephant populations across Africa and Asia. In response, many countries have implemented bans on the sale and importation of ivory products.

a close up view of the black keys on an old piano's musical instrument
a close up view of the black keys on an old piano's musical instrument
an old piano with some black and white keys
an old piano with some black and white keys
an old piano with marble tiles on it's keys and wood grained edges
an old piano with marble tiles on it's keys and wood grained edges

The impact of this crisis has not been lost on the piano industry. In recent years, manufacturers have been forced to confront the ethical implications of their use of ivory and respond to increasing consumer concerns.

Alternatives to Ivory

Faced with these challenges, piano manufacturers have sought out viable alternatives to ivory. Several substances offers similar tactile and aesthetic qualities, including plastics, bone from responsibly-sourced animals, and even recycled materials.

AD

One such alternative iselian, a synthetic ivory created by the piano manufacturer Yamaha. This material replicates the feel and appearance of real ivory without contributing to elephant poaching. Other manufacturers, such as Steinway & Sons, offer instruments with keys crafted from cattle bone, which is considered a byproduct of the meat industry.

Are Piano Keys Made of Ivory?
Are Piano Keys Made of Ivory?
two white tags are attached to a chain
two white tags are attached to a chain
a necklace with a fairy on it and a flower in the center, hanging from a gold chain
a necklace with a fairy on it and a flower in the center, hanging from a gold chain
an old wooden piano with white and brown keys
an old wooden piano with white and brown keys

The Role of Legislation and Certification

Governments around the world have enacted strict laws to combat the illegal ivory trade. For instance, in 1989, the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) called for a global ban on international trade of ivory. In 1990, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES)Appendix I listed African elephants, making all international commercial trade of African elephant products illegal.

Meanwhile, some piano manufacturers have embraced voluntary certifications to reassure consumers that their instruments do not contribute to the illegal ivory trade. For example, Yamaha's 'Eleganza' label certifies that each piano's keys are crafted from synthetic ivory, while Steinway's 'Certified Pre-Owned' program verifies that used instruments do not contain illegal ivory.

AD

The Future of Piano Key Material

The piano industry's shift away from ivory is relatively recent, but it marks a significant change in attitude. As demand for ethical and sustainable products continues to grow, so too will the need for innovative, environmentally-friendly alternatives to ivory. Manufacturers must remain agile and responsive to these trends, continually refining their processes and seeking out new materials.

Moreover, education plays a crucial role in driving this change. Pianists, piano teachers, and enthusiasts should be informed about the issues surrounding ivory and support piano manufacturers that commit to ethical sourcing and sustainable practices.

As we look to the future, it is clear that the piano industry's relationship with ivory is evolving. While the allure of this natural material remains, so does the awareness of its impact on endangered species. By embracing innovation and prioritizing sustainability, the piano industry can continue to provide high-quality instruments without contributing to the destruction of elephant populations. After all, the joy of music should never come at the expense of our natural world.

AD
AD