Cinderella: The Dark Ending of the Original Story
The tale of Cinderella, as recorded by Charles Perrault in the 17th century, is a classic that has been retold countless times, with Disney's iteration being the most popular. However, the original story, with its dark elements and harsh lessons, often takes a backseat in modern retellings. Let's delve into the darker aspects of the original Cinderella story.
Away from the enchanting fairy godmothers and happy endings, the original Cinderella tale, titled "Cendrillon," is a chilling cautionary tale that offers a bleak view of life during Perrault's time. Here, we'll explore the darker sides of this well-known story, including its harsh morality, grim punishments, and the reality of life for women in 17th-century France.
The Harsh Morality of the Original Cinderella Story
The original Cinderella story, while seemingly innocent, is deeply rooted in the societal norms and harsh morality of its time. It serves as a moral lesson, demonstrating the rewards of patience, kindness, and obedience, and the consequences of disobedience and cruelty.
In this tale, Cinderella, a loving and obedient child, is rewarded with happiness, while her stepsisters, cruel and selfish, are punished. This moral message, whilst appealing to many, has a dark side - it can be seen as supporting the status quo and enforcing societal norms without question, particularly regarding women's roles.
The Cruelty of the Stepmother and Stepsisters
In Perrault's version, Cinderella's stepmother is not just cold, but outright cruel. She not only makes Cinderella work as a servant but also humbles her and inflicts physical harm. This portrayal reflects the harsh realities of life for many women in 17th-century France, who often faced abuse and had little to no legal protection.
The stepsisters, too, are not just mean, but downright villainous. They not only abuse Cinderella but also attempt to impersonate her to claim the prince's love. This represents the societal expectation for women to be beautiful and wife-like, and the severe consequences faced by those who stepped out of line.
The Grim Reality of Cinderella's Life
Cinderella's life, as depicted in the original tale, is one of servitude and misery. She is reduced to sleeping among the cinders in the kitchen, earning her name. This harsh reality reflects the lives of many lower-class women in Perrault's time, who often faced a life of hard labor and little prospect of escape.
Despite her hardships, Cinderella remains optimistic and kind, hoping for a better life. This, sadly, is a testament to the resilience of many women throughout history who, despite adversity, held onto hope.
The Dark and Often Overlooked Ending
Perrault's version of Cinderella ends with a touch of darkness that is often ignored in modern retellings. After Cinderella and the Prince marry, the stepsisters attend the wedding. Despite their acts of cruelty, they are not turned away but welcomed, highlighting the societal expectation for unity and forgiveness, even in the face of abuse.
The true dark twist comes at the end. In a scene reminiscent of the Biblical story of David and Goliath, the birds that had been helping Cinderella (a nod to the fairy godmother in other versions) peck out the eyes of the stepsisters. Perrault writes that the birds then "fall like stones and kill them on the spot," a grim and violent end, serving as a final reminder of the consequences of cruelty.
In revisiting the original Cinderella story, we're reminded of the harsh realities of life for women in 17th-century France. Despite its dark elements and harsh lessons, Cinderella's tale remains a timeless testament to hope, resilience, and the power of kindness. However, it's crucial to remember the full story, dark aspects and all, to truly appreciate its historical and cultural significance.