cinderella original story grimm ending

Cinderella's Tragic End: Grimm's Original Story

By Melissa White
AD

The Brothers Grimm's original telling of "Cinderella" significantly differs from the Disney version we're familiar with today, ending not with a happily ever after, but with a gruesome foot-mutilation scene. This stark contrast begs the question: how did the story evolve to become the fairy tale we know, and what can we learn from its original ending?

To understand the untold chapters of Cinderella's tale, we must delve into the archive of the Grimm brothers, Jacob and Wilhelm, who collected folk stories from Germany in the early 1800s. Their original version, titled "Aschenputtel," barely resembles the cinematic masterpiece produced by Disney. By exploring the differences and evolution of the story, we can uncover a rich history that reveals much about storytelling and societal shifts over time.

The Original Cinderella: A Dark Fairytale

The Grimms' version starts like the Disney film, with a girl mistreated by her stepmother and stepsisters. However, the tale quickly takes a dark turn, with the protagonist Aschenputtel (Cinderella) helped not by fairy godmothers, but by a magical tree and a white bird that were her father's gifts from the house spirit.

AD
When Fairy Tales Weren’t For Kids
When Fairy Tales Weren’t For Kids
Cinderella by Isaac
Cinderella by Isaac
Cinderella - Dark Original Version by Brothers Grimm 1812
Cinderella - Dark Original Version by Brothers Grimm 1812

Here, the pacing is unfamiliar: the story jumps from Aschenputtel's mistreatment to her attending three balls, the prince falling in love, and finding her identity. Unlike Disney's slow build-up, the Grimm tale races through plot points, focusing less on character development and more on narrative momentum.

grisly ending: the foot-mutilation scene

Aschenputtel's tale concludes with a scene that's chilling, gruesome, and utterly unlike Disney's. After the prince discovers Cinderella's true identity by comparing the slipper to her foot, the two wicked stepsisters become enraged and try to fit the slipper on their feet. To achieve this, they cut off parts of their toes and heal them using pigeon blood, a nod to the white bird's role in the story.

シンデレラ
シンデレラ
the storyboard shows different scenes from disney's beauty and the beast, including princesses
the storyboard shows different scenes from disney's beauty and the beast, including princesses
a drawing of a woman sitting on the ground next to a broom and other items
a drawing of a woman sitting on the ground next to a broom and other items

Their deception fails, and at the wedding, the pigeons (in some versions, the doves from the first ball) peck at their eyes and pick out their eyes, leaving them blind as punishment for their cruelty. The original Cinderella ends with Aschenputtel marrying the prince, and her stepsisters suffering a horrible fate, but also married – to a couple of apes, in one of the earliest versions.

The Evolution of Cinderella: From Dark to Disney

Cinderella's evolution from a dark folk tale to a sanitized Disney princess story reflects changes in societal norms, storytelling formats, and audience preferences. In the 19th century, stories were often presented as moral lessons, with punishments fitting the crime. Later, as literature targeted children, violence and gore were toned down, leading to the familiar, G-rated tale we know today.

AD

Charles Perrault's French version, "Cendrillon," also played a part in shaping the story we now tell. Published in 1697, it ギ Applied several changes: the fairy godmother, the pumpkin coach, the glass slipper, and the lietmotif – an elegant glass slipper that can fit only Aschenputtel's foot. These elements found their way into Disney's animated film and subsequent adaptations.

Cinderella by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm — narrated and illustrated
Cinderella by Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm — narrated and illustrated
an image of children in costume playing with each other on the cover of a book
an image of children in costume playing with each other on the cover of a book
the princess and the frog are talking to each other in front of an old - fashioned castle
the princess and the frog are talking to each other in front of an old - fashioned castle
Cinderella — Vintage Fairy Tale Infographic | Classic Storybook Art
Cinderella — Vintage Fairy Tale Infographic | Classic Storybook Art
Cinderella and the Doves | Grimm Fairy Tale 灰かぶりと鳩たち|グリム童話
Cinderella and the Doves | Grimm Fairy Tale 灰かぶりと鳩たち|グリム童話
a comic strip with an image of two people talking to each other and one person holding a
a comic strip with an image of two people talking to each other and one person holding a

Learning from the Original: Moral, Engagement, and Authenticity

The Brothers Grimm's Cinderella offers valuable insights into story crafting and understanding our storytelling heritage. The stark contrast with Disney's version shows the importance of knowing your audience and adapting the narrative accordingly. The original tale's dark elements remind us that not all stories need to be tailored for young children, and that adults can appreciate raw, disturbing, and intriguing elements in stories.

The original ending, with its gruesome punishment, serves as a cautionary tale, emphasizing consequences for cruelty and deceit. Today, we might find this thin on nuance and heavy-handed, but it's essential to consider such stories in their historical context and recognize their underlying moral messages.

AD

Engaging with Original Fairy Tales: A Richer Storytelling Experience

Reading the original Cinderella opens up a world of untold stories, inviting us to question popular narratives and examine the evolution of fairy tales. Engaging with these texts allows us to appreciate not only the familiar Disney adaptation but also the rich, complex history of storytelling.

BILL RANDALL
BILL RANDALL

Moreover, exploring these tales offers a glimpse into the past, helping us understand societal shifts and cultural norms. From punishment to character development, the journey of Cinderella tells a story of its own, reflecting the evolution of audiences, storytellers, and the art of spinning yarns.

In conclusion, delving into the original "Cinderella" szeresse reveals a dark, gruesome tale that underwent dramatic changes en route to becoming a Disney classic. By exploring this transformation, we gain insight into storytelling and societal evolution, appreciating the intricate tapestry of our literary heritage. So, the next time you hum "Bibbidi-Bobbidi-Boo," remember the dark magic and gruesome punishments that once defined Cinderella's story, and consider the equally enchanting, if less familiar, world of original fairy tales.

AD
AD